Whaddaya reckon?

Started by radmaggot, February 13, 2012, 09:07:53 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

radmaggot

Backs: Goddard, Deledio, Grimes, Lake, Clarke, Bugg, Morris
         (Smedts, Brown)
Mids: Ablett, Swan, Murphy, Hayes, Morabito, Mitchell
         (Hampton, Shiel)
Rucks: Goldstien, Mumford
         (Stephenson, Giles)
Forwards: Franklin, Fyfe, Rioli, Brown, Porplyzia, Zorko, Treloar
         (Kerridge, Frank)

Still have $410,000 left but nice to have a lil feedback.
I like rioli especially as no one has gone for him, taking a punt with
morabito. Rookies could be anyone

radmaggot

cmon guys help a brother out

Ringo

You have got a nice amount of cash left so use it.

Backs: Grimes at D3 and then Lake and Clarke.  You will be giving away points with that structure, Look at getting in another proven prem Shaw, Fisher, Suckling, Birchall etc. while upgrading a rookie.
Mids: Sound - There are a few threads on Mora which you should read prior to locking him in but may be ok.
Rucks: Can not fault
Forwards: Sound.

Rating 7.5/10 mainly due to perceived weakness with back structure,  Good luck.

Mushi

Quote from: Ringo on February 14, 2012, 07:35:58 PM
You have got a nice amount of cash left so use it.

Backs: Grimes at D3 and then Lake and Clarke.  You will be giving away points with that structure, Look at getting in another proven prem Shaw, Fisher, Suckling, Birchall etc. while upgrading a rookie.
Mids: Sound - There are a few threads on Mora which you should read prior to locking him in but may be ok.
Rucks: Can not fault
Forwards: Sound.

Rating 7.5/10 mainly due to perceived weakness with back structure,  Good luck.

Bugg to Enright, problem solved, Lake and Grimes is just risk vs reward

craig22

Morabito will be playing wafl for a few rounds i read in the west australian

radmaggot

Thanks, really appreciate that. wondering what the word is with porps, could be a good gamble, although i have a few, (hayes, lake, grimes) Will enright go as well as previous i wonder?

radmaggot

Ok made a few changes here, there is some risk but i think there should be

    Backs: Goddard, Delidio, Shaw, Grimes, Lake, Clark, Smedts
              (Morris, Brown)
    Mids: Ablett, Swan, Murphy, Caddy, Morabito, Shiel
            (Hampton, Zorko)
    Rucks: Mumford, Stephenson
              (Giles, Rowe)
    Forwards: Franklin, Fyfe, Johnson, Rioli, Goodes, Porplyzia, Treloar
                  (Kerridge, Crozier)

    $12,500 left

   3 rook mid, three rook ruck, i know...... gives good strength elsewhere though, could be a great gamble. Love some feedback

Ringo

You are correct with some risks and i do not mind a couple.
Backs: Sound but you have the Grimes Lake issue which is well documented.
Mids: If going the three mids. 3 rook strategy you will need rooks that will rise in cash quickly so just ensure you pick the right ones after NAB cup.  Do not think Mora will fit that bill but caddy might.
Rucks: Standard for those going 1 prem 3 rook strategy.
Forwards Again very Sound.

Rate 8/10 Good luck with the risks you are taking.