Main Menu

please rate

Started by mark621, February 15, 2012, 06:35:22 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

mark621

Hi all, plunging myself into the ff world.

Please rate and i hope my feedback on others is ok.

Def: goddard, Scotland, suckling, grimes, Clarke, Nigel, smedts, siera, morris
Mid: swallow.a, Watson, montag, shirt, barlow, wingard (questioning for cheaper rookie), miles, l.brown
Tuck: mummy, nice Nat, dericks, stephenson
Fwd: rioli, gray, nroo, lecras, j.brown, t.Adams, sexton, Hampton, rowe



Any feedback is much appreciated

mark621

Sorry have 80k in the bank. Figured that's why I haven't heard much

tor01doc

Suspect you haven't heard much because there is too much to say.

Who is Shirt?
No super premium mids?
LeCras not to my liking for his price.
Only Rioli as a gun forward - but potentially NRoo / JB / Gray coudl fire but need more reliable players.

Good luck.





mark621

Bloody iphones

Shirt: shuey

I believe that gaz and pendles will both drop in value by at least 7-10% so they are on a upgrade list.
And lecras have been thinking on to goodes by bringing Scotland down to brouggton and having him as an upgrade.

Swallow and Watson to jump into top 5 and montag back into top 10

fever

sorry man but back to the drawing board.

def is passable (i assume "nigel" is an iphone issue?)

mids are too weak but with too many high priced players

fwds you need some quality. lose some mid pricers and upgrade.

mark621

Ffs iphones are shower.

Grimes should be.

mark621

Revised

Def: goddard, Scotland, suckling, broughton, Clarke, mohr, smeldts, siera, morris
Mid: a.swallow, Watson,montag, treleor, barlow, zorko (may change), miles, l.brown
Ruck: mummy, mcevoy, Giles, stephenson
Fwd: rioli, gray, nroo, goodes, pavlich, t.Adams, sexton,Hampton, rowe

mark621


fever

pretty solid. lack of real midfield dynamos, but the 4 prems you have are capable of stepping up a bracket. defence is a tad thin. i think there are better fwd rookies than def so maybe downgrade gray or roo to a rookie then up a def rookie to delidio, shaw or fisher.