would love some feedback fellas.

ando_10 · February 20, 2012, 04:44:20 PM

backs: goddard,Scotland, H.shaw, enright, clarke, ellis, smedts
emg: bugg morris

mids: ablett, swan, dal santo, shuey, lucas,treloar
emg: browne, gibson

rucks: mumford, giles
emg: derickx, stephenson

forwards: franklin, fyfe, johnson, martin, brown, pfeiffer, hampton
emg: weedon, kerridge.

12k left

mt_williams22 · February 20, 2012, 06:34:03 PM

Looking good!
- Adcock's a nice unique in the back.
- As is Dal Santo in the middle, like Shuey (just couldnt fit him in to my team), see if lucas is going to play, otherwise downgrade and use cash elsewhere
- Rucks are a little weak having Giles on the field (but the rest of your field is strong because of it)
- like Johnson as a unique ( havent seen anyone with him yet), not sold on pfeiffer or weedon...time will tell!

Overall a solid team! Could downgrade a few prems to scape together some cash and get a better 2nd ruckman.
8.5/10

mt_williams22 · February 20, 2012, 06:59:12 PM

Also, can you please rate my team (should be a few posts down)

ando_10 · February 20, 2012, 07:13:35 PM

Quote from: mt_williams22 on February 20, 2012, 06:34:03 PM
Looking good!
- Adcock's a nice unique in the back.
- As is Dal Santo in the middle, like Shuey (just couldnt fit him in to my team), see if lucas is going to play, otherwise downgrade and use cash elsewhere
- Rucks are a little weak having Giles on the field (but the rest of your field is strong because of it)
- like Johnson as a unique ( havent seen anyone with him yet), not sold on pfeiffer or weedon...time will tell!

Overall a solid team! Could downgrade a few prems to scape together some cash and get a better 2nd ruckman.
8.5/10

cheers dude.

will keep it in mind i heard lucas dominated carlton intra club and been killing time trials so will be keeping an ear out.

felsty · February 20, 2012, 07:38:47 PM

B: Like it a lot. like you said about my side with adcock as third was looking to upgrde heppell, thinking jed will rip it up but! rest is perfect

M: excellent again! dont know if dal santo can keep up his form from last season but still going to be a big scorer as will shuey although he went missing in games last year so little bit of a risk for me

R: perfect!

F: i like a lot, just a few rookies im a bit suss about.. weedon, pfeiffer, gibson... dont think nab cup is the greatest way to see blokes play 40min of football.. id like to see some consistency first but time will tell

all in all 8.5/10, loving it ;)

ando_10 · February 20, 2012, 07:52:38 PM

Quote from: felsty on February 20, 2012, 07:38:47 PM
B: Like it a lot. like you said about my side with adcock as third was looking to upgrde heppell, thinking jed will rip it up but! rest is perfect

M: excellent again! dont know if dal santo can keep up his form from last season but still going to be a big scorer as will shuey although he went missing in games last year so little bit of a risk for me

R: perfect!

F: i like a lot, just a few rookies im a bit suss about.. weedon, pfeiffer, gibson... dont think nab cup is the greatest way to see blokes play 40min of football.. id like to see some consistency first but time will tell

all in all 8.5/10, loving it ;)

cheers buddy

yeah well pfeiffer will get elevated cause hitchcock is on the LTI list
and i saw gibson play a fair bit last year and is a ball magnet and weedon is just there for the time being haha.

Junktimer · February 21, 2012, 09:50:01 PM

Quote from: ando_10 on February 20, 2012, 04:44:20 PM
backs: goddard, H.shaw, enright, adcock, clarke, ellis, smedts
emg: bugg morris

mids: ablett, swan, dal santo, shuey, lucas,treloar
emg: browne, gibson

rucks: mumford, giles
emg: derickx, stephenson

forwards: franklin, fyfe, johnson, martin, brown, pfeiffer, hampton
emg: weedon, kerridge.

54k left

Defence: enright is unique, but is probably safe. Adcock is up and down, injury prone. Heard a whisper of an injury to marty clarke, watch this space, apart from that looks good.

Midfield: love it. youve spent a bit, but those uniques will pay off, shuey and lucas = guns, dont let people tell you otherwise, if only i had the cojones to put them in my side. Im gonna assume by "browne" you mean luke brown? Dal is expensive, but has been an SC veteran over the year and shouldn't change.

Rucks: fine.

Forwards: fine, good premiums.

Overall i really like your team and i think you have a few good PODs. 3 premiums in the mids could be risky but i genuinely think shuey can score massively this year. Lovely work.

The Supercoach · February 23, 2012, 10:59:55 PM

Backs: Look very good, dont mind adcock and even enright who hasn't been in that many teams

Mids: Dal had a great year last and i think he will be able to keep it up so nice unique, shuey also risky but i like the look of him

Rucks: Mummy should dominate, Giles risky but dont mind that strategy

Fwds: Looking great, not much to say there

Overall good looking team 8/10 :)