Rate please!

[bindas123]

Backs : Scotland, Deledio, Shaw, Grimes, Lake, Clarke, Bower.....Ellis, Smedts
Mids : Ablett, Swan, Selwood, Goddard, Shiel, McDonald....Miles, Mitchell
Rucks : Sandilands, Kreuzer....Giles, Stephensen
Forwards : Franklin, Chapman, Riewoldt, Didak, Porplyzia, Byrnes, Pfeiffer... Zorko, Hampton

Cash Left :85k

Thanks..

[GT-1988]

lots of uniques in this team that could pay of with big bucks but at big risks

any reason goddard in the midfield rather than back ?

also cannot see byrnes getting a gig with the young talent at geelong in the same positions e.g christianson and pehaps menzels when he get back possibly round 10.

also doubt james mcdonald and bower will get much match time pobably better off going a young talent such as mohr or morris for bower

[bindas123]

Goddard in the midfield to give me a MPP option..
good point on byrnes,,,I just really rate him but I guess the coaching stuff don't
Thanks for the tips mate..

[dmac07]

Dont mind Goddard in the mids, as the season moves on though would swap him to the backs with one of your b/m rookies. As you'd rather upgrade to an extra mid premium than back premium.

Otherwise a few good uniques, like scotland, not sold on Kruezer but thats your call. Not sure on one or all of Riewoldt, Didak, Porplyzia and Byrnes in the forward line. Would probably turn Byrnes into a rookie and upgrade Didak or Porplyzia to a more reliable fwd premium. Perhaps Cloke, Martin, Goodes.

[Ringo]

Would move Goddard back to defence where he belongs at the expense of Grimes.
Watch the form of Rookies Luke Brown, Jackson Allen and Sam Docherty in NAB cup and if ok select one for your Mid bench to open up the DPP link rather than using a prem. Replace Goddard in mids with Barlow.
If not comfortable with Kreuzer in Rucks maybe look at Zac Smith
Agree with Dmac on forward options

[bindas123]

Thanks Guys.. ok I have changed the team a little bit...please let me know what you think ?
Backs : Scotland, Deledio, Shaw, Grimes, Lake, Clarke, Ellis.....Ellis, Morris
Mids : Ablett, Swan, Selwood, Goddard, Shiel, McDonald....Miles, Mitchell
Rucks : Sandilands, McEvoy....Giles, Stephensen
Forwards : Franklin, Chapman, Riewoldt, Goodes, Zorko, Hampton, Dick... Rowe, T Couch

[PICCOLLO]

Very good.  Bye friendly with mpp too.  Unsure about chappy.  It would be wise to ensure you have some coin in the bank too.
8.5/10

[bindas123]

Great thanks mate... very happy with Chappy..I'll know he'll get rested at some point, but still think he'll be worth keeping!