a swans ranga or a porpus?

Started by cortez, February 09, 2012, 11:59:53 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Which cheap forward?

Gary Rohan
Jason Porplyzia

cortez

Please vote and keave a comment if you can. Cheers.

ando_10

Quote from: cortez on February 09, 2012, 11:59:53 AM
Please vote and keave a comment if you can. Cheers.

porps

rohan is over rated (fantasy wise)

cortez

The difference between the two is a lot more more to me than just the players.

If i pick porpus my forward line besides rookies will be:
Buddy, Goodes, Pav, Chappy, Porpus.

If i pick Rohan it wil be:
Pav, Chappy, Rioli, Martin, Rohan.

Which formation is better?


charliesheen

watch rohan's role in NAB cup could be unique pick.

too early to call, but I would say porps for now.

Colliwobblers

Quote from: cortez on February 09, 2012, 01:46:03 PM
The difference between the two is a lot more more to me than just the players.

If i pick porpus my forward line besides rookies will be:
Buddy, Goodes, Pav, Chappy, Porpus.

If i pick Rohan it wil be:
Pav, Chappy, Rioli, Martin, Rohan.

Which formation is better?

well ignoring popus and rohan

option 1 you have 3 premiums on the round 12 bye so skip it for that reason alone. Leaves option 2 and upgrade to goodes he finished every season better than he starts it anyway.

YOUNG24

Been trying to decide out of these 2 as well - Rohan as a unique, Porps for pure value.

Whether Rohan can hold down a spot in the 22 and not be vested is what worries me...

Capper

Quote from: ando_10 on February 09, 2012, 12:28:41 PM
Quote from: cortez on February 09, 2012, 11:59:53 AM
Please vote and keave a comment if you can. Cheers.

porps

rohan is over rated (fantasy wise)

massive call and i disagree

Rohan is coming into his third year after an injury last year and will tear it up. Porps is too broken for me


Bosh

Rohan should be ready to take a step up this year coming into his 3rd yet, but still wouldn't pick him. Personally, wouldn't pick porpz either a rookie would be better value giving you an extra 110k.

Capper

Quote from: Bosh on February 09, 2012, 05:58:03 PM
Rohan should be ready to take a step up this year coming into his 3rd yet, but still wouldn't pick him. Personally, wouldn't pick porpz either a rookie would be better value giving you an extra 110k.

+1 Rohan or Jetta will have the green jacket on this year

essendon33

go the porps, word is he is fit and firing.. maybe playing more midfield time this year :O

majorly consistant player when he strings games together easily 80+ avg if he does!

reesbr

Rohan killed the intra club mathc. I'm on him..

Colliwobblers

Quote from: reesbr on February 11, 2012, 12:47:20 PM
Rohan killed the intra club mathc. I'm on him..

read that, i cant get on him becasue the bye is killing my fwd line already have (want to have)

Round 12 bye

1. Goodes
2. Zaka
3. Sidebottom

It can't be 4 so rohan is out ill go porps or a rook, the only other option for me would be to upgrade rohan and get him out by round 12. Still I'm tempted, he got a big wrap in that write up you refer to