Rate my team!!

Started by JimMundy93, February 08, 2012, 10:48:41 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

JimMundy93

please rate my team. Im curious to know what you guys think

Defenders: Goddard, Deledio, Shaw, Grimes, Buntine, Clarke, Morris (Smedts, sieakowski)
Mids: Ablett, Dal Santo, Murphy, Rockliff, Barlow, Shiel (Kavanagh, Magner)
Rucks: Mumford, H Mac (Giles, Stephenson)
Forwards: Goodes, Martin, Zaharakis, LeCras, Pfeiffer, Saad, Zorko (Walsh, Williams)

CrowsFan

Hey Jim, here are my thoughts :)

Defenders - Top 3 very solid picks. Grimes always a risk with injuries, but should do very well if stays fit. Can't really fault the rookies, maybe downgrade Buntine to a cheaper rook so you have spare cash available. Sierakowski and interesting choice, to be honest I haven't heard anything about him.

Mids - Extremely strong all the way through. Just make sure Magner is elevated from the rookie list. If he gets games he should score very well as a mature age player from the WAFL.

Rucks - Can't fault it. I'm personally going for the standard 2 prem, 2 rookie approach, but can understand why people want H Mac.

Forwards - I think you are possibly a little weak in the forward line, but obviously because you have stacked your mids. Also is that Williams from the Demons? I don't think he will get many games to be honest since he is still on the rookie list. Melbourne can't promote Magner and Williams since they only get one spot.

Overall I think the team is looking good for now. Just keep an eye on the rookies in the NAB cup, and maybe try and strengthen up the forwards. If you downgrade Buntine you could get some cash to upgrade LeCras to a prem :)

JimMundy93

Yeah I was always planning on getting rid of Williams for Walsh

My forward line has some method behind the madness, I think zaharakis is in for a really good year, and leCras has been rumored to play mid and if he does I see him averaging well

If buntine looks good I'll keep him because I feel he can score high, but I'll definitely wait and see if magner gets promoted

Thanks for the feedback

nathan11

le cras was meant toget mid time last year as well and it never happened so be careful with that pick