Midfield Dilemma

[Chelskiman]

God I hate byes. 

Anyway, I originally had a mid of Swan, Ablett, J. Selwood and Barlow but the bye then freaked me out so I went Selwood to Murphy so I would only lose two premiums max for the round 12 bye.  Trouble is I really did want Selwood, but to do that I'd need to get rid of Swan or Barlow, and sorry Barlow, you might be good value, but Swan is going to outrank you every time.  So my thought was to either keep Swan/Ablett/Murphy/Barlow or go Barlow to Hayes and Murph back to Selwood.

tl;dr

Which looks stronger

Swan, Ablett, Murphy, Barlow

Swan, Ablett, Selwood, Hayes

If possible please give reasons for your vote.  Cheers, fellas!

[Justin Bieber]

The first one, cause Marc Murphy will score better as well as Barlow.

[Torpedo10]

I wouldn't choose either.

[Kuruki]

Im having the same problem. How shower is it that we cant have Pendels Swan Selwood and Barlow together untill after round 12. I would have all of them in my side round 1 if we didnt have those damn bye's. I really want Selwood but i cant lose Barlow because of the upside he has. So instead of ditching Swan or Pendels. I have decided the best option is just to give up on Selwood and go Murphy.
That gives me an even 2 2 2 bye spread in my 6 mid spots. And yes it's very relevant even in round1.  ;)

[Adamant]

Mate I have the exact same problem my current MIDS consist of
Swan, Ablett, Jelwood, Barlow - but in round 12 I will have 3 Guns out.
Cant get rid of Swanny, a gun and will outscore everyone this season DT wise.
Cant get rid of Barlow as he is AWESOME value and should get back to 100+ average.
So that leaves Jelwood to get rid of and grab Rockliff.
I really want Jelwood though as he is underpriced and can definatley see him averaging 115+. Im thinking of just sacrificing that round. GOD I HATE BYES!

[Chelskiman]

Looks pretty conclusive so far!

[chatters24]

Certainly would go with Murphy/Barlow. Worried about Hayes comeback from injury particularly at his age.

[lordy9]

the fist one is the same as my midfield and im happy with it ;D