1st-time DT'er - Any feedback would be appreciated

Started by lukeshuey, February 28, 2012, 05:33:02 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

lukeshuey

BACKS: B. Goddard (St.K), B. Deledio (Rich), J. Grimes (Melb), B. Waters (WCE), B. Lake (Bull), M. Clarke (Coll), T. Mohr (GWS), B. Smedts (Geel), B. Wilkes (St.K)

MID: D. Swan (Coll), M. Boyd (Bull), G. Ablett (GC), L. Shuey (WCE), A. Morabito (Fre), D. Shiel (GWS), L. Neale (Fre), J. McDonald (GWS).

RUCK: D. Cox (WCE), H. McIntosh (Kang), J Giles (GWS), O. Stephenson (Geel)

FWD: S. Johnson (Geel), L. Franklin (Haw), N. Fyfe (Fre), D. Martin (Rich), J. Porplyzia (Ade), S. Byrnes (Geel), M. Brown (Geel), A. Saad (St.K), D. Zorko (Bris).

$76,800 left in the bank. Considering downgrading either byrnes or brown, in order to upgrade porplyzia to maybe J. Brown...

Capper

Is Morabito playing yet or he is still out with an injury???

Not a bad team, definitely put together by a WC supporter

Players to watch Deleidio, Grimes, Waters, Lake, Clarke, Morabito, Porplyzia, Zorko - make sure all these players are fit and ready to go as they are all either coming back from injuries last year or currently are injured

Justin Bieber

Not bad, reallly risky backs which probably won't pay off
Strong mids
Yeah H_Mac, not sure....
Byrnes and Porps in the same team? not really sure about it

Not the greatest team, I've see and don't expect to win the car. Sorry mate, don't hate me.

Big_Shazza

Backs: very risky with grimes, waters and lake better options out there

Mids: not bad but watch morabito as coming back from ACL injury

Rucks: great with cox but hmac shares the samebye along with giles

Fwds: pretty strong just dont like porps in there

overall 6/10

PowerBug

Backs: Need to find a third premium in your Backs, with Grimes injured use him as the upgrade. No issues with the rookies.

Mids: first three: 10/10 no issues there. Drop either Shuey or Morabito (or both) to rookies or someone like Sloane. Rookies and Jmac are cool. Just watch Shiel closely as he may not pull up for rd 1. (Magner, Hampton are a couple to watch)

Rucks: HMac i'm not sold on, but many have him so not a bad decision. Other 3 are good.

Fwds: first 4 are good, Maybe drop Porps, Brown and Byrnes to geniune rookies (Pfeiffer (DPP Mids), Cameron, Couch are some to watch)

From there you should find enough $$$ to upgrade Grimes.

Not the worst team i've seen on here :)

LEV

BACKS.
Grimes, Waters and Lake a HUGE risk having all them. Grimes now injured as PB pointed out.  I would take out lake and put hargrave in his place.

MIDS.
Moribito needs to go, too much of a risk IMO. Downgrade to a rookie and use the cash elsewhere.
http://www.afl.com.au/news/newsarticle/tabid/208/newsid/129751/default.aspx

I would get rid of shuey too, whilst he will do ok i think he wont be consistent enough.

RUCKS.
If you're going to have Hmac, you might as well be playing Giles on the ground instead and use the money elsewhere.

FORWARDS.
Drop Porps and Byrnes and use the combined money to get a rookie plus a better player. Would also downgrade stevie J (i see him as an upgrade target, he will drop in price early on me thinks :)) Dont know about Brown from Geelong either.

BTW i would stay away from J.Brown, he is simply having no luck!!
http://www.afl.com.au/news/newsarticle/tabid/208/newsid/129754/default.aspx

Good effort mate, but definitely needs some tweaking to compete with a whole lot of other teams out there.

PB's post seems to cover most of it anyway :)


Justin Bieber

Like lev said, 3 players got injured or had a setback so maybe upgrade one, downgrade two?