DEF Premiums???

Started by oconnell, February 20, 2012, 06:09:26 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

who will score the most points this year?

Shaw
Enright
Scotland
Broughton

oconnell

^^ please vote and leave a comment of what u think

Cheers :)

MC

Top 4 in order should be: Goddard>Delidio>Shaw>Birchall imo

(So Shaw from those options)

4INAROW

i'd go shaw, had an embarrassing year last year due to being a flowerwit and will want to pay his team back.
also the loss of the flag will drive him i think.

scotland will drop a lil bit imo, probably just purely because of age and pace.

enright doesn't have the same experienced players down back helping him out as he has in recent years.

broughton could and may well challenge shaw for top spot if a permanent move to the midfield is made, but it's hard to judge seeing as he rotated with someone through the mids and def last night, not sure who it was maybe duffy.

that's my reasoning anyway, correct me if i'm wrong guys.

mt_williams22

Goddard -  didnt have as strong of a season as was expected, so will bounce back and dominate again.

Scotland - carlton should push for a top 4 spot, if not the flag.  Will roam around and rack of disposals with great effectiveness as usual.

Shaw - also plays for a flag contending team, so will score close to or over 100 most weeks, but has the ability to have a few off weeks a season.

Delideo - conssistantly averaging around 104 for the past 4 years, enright will drop off.

burner11


Usman

Broughton could if he plays mid but i doubt it. Enright is getting on and Geelong wont be better than last year so cant see him improving.Scotland is a chance with an improving Carlton but he is getting on aswell. Shaw is my pick in a good team and a game plan that minimises the effect of a forward tag.

4INAROW

sorry to jump in on your thread oconnell, but ive got a similar dilemna with my backs, ive got goddard, shaw, deledio and room for another premium, money no issue. thoughts?

oconnell

Quote from: 4INAROW on February 20, 2012, 09:26:35 PM
sorry to jump in on your thread oconnell, but ive got a similar dilemna with my backs, ive got goddard, shaw, deledio and room for another premium, money no issue. thoughts?

na its alright thats pretty much what im trying to work out as well

4INAROW

yeah it's hard without knowing if broughton will get more mid time?, does scotland still have the legs to run it out of defence?, how will the emergence of some young hawthorn players affect birchall's role?

alot of questions hopefully answered in the coming weeks i suppose.