Chapman vs Buddy

[tassieguns]

 ;)

[JamSainter]

I reckon Chappy could be a real unique but at the moment I don't have the balls to pick him over Franklin, time will tell though!

[ShaynoB]

Go buddy! If Chappy holds up he'll b perfect upgrade target as his price I reckon will drop a lil

[Chelskiman]

Upgrade target if he can find some of his old form.  Buddy is a starter for me, it's that simple.

[Purple 77]

Buddy.

Chapman I think is getting on a bit

[JamSainter]

Geelong has an easier draw than Hawthorn and Buddy has more money to lose... but I must admit, my team does look a lot better with Buddy in it!

[thatguy]

you will definitely be going unique from the top sides without buddy. most ''contenders'' will start with him.

chappy is an interesting one, apparently tearing up the track at the moment

[owenbond007]

Go buddy! If Chappy holds up he'll b perfect upgrade target as his price I reckon will drop a lil

Im of the opposite view. I think chappy is a more consistent perform and reports r he is training well and is very fit. Buddy is great but can occasionally not rack up em due to numerous reasons (eg doubled team, Scarlett like defender has a good day. Using this logic im hoping by r7 or 8 i can upgrade a rookie or porp to buddy.

[browny_wce]

your a buddy idiot mate  8)

pretty simple decision

Sir Lancelot of Franklonia

[Football Factory]

Bad Boy Buddy

[Kuruki]

Stop making life hard for yourself and just get both. I have. hehe

[me]

i'd actually take the bigger risk and go chappy for greater reward - or just get both

you cannot ignore the bald knight given his preseason, and should whack out some IMMENSE scores while buddy is getting triple teamed against collingwood/geelong/westcoast

just realised chappy is only 30, and will be 30 the whole season, he's not that old (or as ancient as i thought)

[yorgis]

you said it me buddy's got a bit of hard start to the season and should dro[p a bit in price but chappy, well he's just chappy

[stew42]

Just realised I could go both... my fwds went from
Franklin, Goods, Fyfe
to
Chappy, Franklin, Goodes... WINNAGE