Version 3 - Rate or Hate please

[pudmott]

Here is my latest tweaking

DEF: Goddard, Shaw, Deledio, Grimes, Lake, Clarke, Mohr (Smedts, Bugg)

MID: Swan, Ablett, Scotland, Goodes, Pfeiffer, Shiel (Aylett, Brown)

RUC: Cox, Mumford (Giles, Stephensen)

FWD: Johnson, Franklin, Fyfe, N Riewoldt, Byrnes, Zorko, Treloar (Hampton, Sexton)

$40,600 left in the bank and havent looked at byes yet

[SOS#1]

A little risky having both grimes and lake, but I can see the upside in both of them and it is very tempting!

Scotland is an interesting pic in ur mids, obviously there for the mpp link. Not much better options out there tho I believe he is a bit overpriced

I like ur guts with Byrnes. Soooo cheap and if given a good run will make you plenty of cash and could potentially become a 6th-7th fwd keeper

Ur rookies are a little iffy at this stage, but NAB cup will sort that out :)

[TheMailman]

Byrnes is cheap for a reason.

Didn't do well last year at all

Why would he change this year?

Saying, "He's fitter/better this year" doesn't really cut it seeing as all of his rival positoners are much younger and quite frankly better.

Downgrade Scotland to Barlow then upgrade Byrnes to someone more useful

[its me lads]

not happy with grimes and lake in def

scotland could be put into def and a better ave mid put in. also i would steer clear of goodes i think he finished he best footy.

rucks are great could always downgrade mummy a bit if u need cash but i would keep it like it is.

byrnes is a big risk and i dont think riewoldt is worth getting

[TheMailman]

Potentially what you could do is downgrade Cox to another good ruckman (Leunburger, Kreuzer, Jacobs etc.)

Use the money and change Riewoldt to Goodes then change Goodes from the midfield into someone better/more expensive

Goodes' mpp in the mids isn't really needed if you put in players like Zorko or Pfieffer

[pudmott]

Awesome thanks for the advice guys

[Matticus]

Byrnes only played 5 last year so tread carefully, he is also getting older, point being, he isn't getting games though inexperience. Also fyfe had something wrong with him late last year and i am pretty sure he is only doing light pre-season.  ;D