Coniglio or J-Mac?

[Adamant]

Is Coniglio's JS worth the extra 70k? and is J-Mac a prime candidate for the vest being 35 years old? already got Shiel, Magnet & Devon Smith (DPP link) in the mids...

[Justin Bieber]

J Mac will play more games than Dan Harris last year. Lock before byes.

[Jukes]

Coniglio is an out and out gun, will average 10 more then other midfield rookies. Well worth the extra $$$.

[Ricochet]

Def Coniglio. Has JS, will score and i feel that Jmac will wear the vest more that him

[Artax]

Think Coniglio is worth taking over Clifton or Miles? Looking to start 2 of the 3

[mezzoculo]

Why is there no both option? Coniglio could become a keeper while McD should be the ultimate early season cash cow.

[Rommas]

I got Coniglio as my 6th mid and McDonald on the bench as the cash cow, that's probably the more safe way to do it if you can do so

[Bak2Form]

J Mac will play more games than Dan Harris last year. Lock before byes.

+1

jmac too cheap to ignore

[ubeaut]

MacDonald has me in two minds. On one hand yes he seems like the ultimate cash cow. On the other there is huge midfield depth at GWS Coniglio,MacDonald,Miles,Kennedy,Shiel,Tyson,Smith,Treloar,Palmer,Scully,Ward,Clifton etc. Will he play enough games early to make $$$? We will have to put up with the GWS rotational policy just like GC last season. I'm wary of picking GWS players for this reason. On the other hand if you pick heaps on the same line you should have enough playing each week. And the other rookie options are few and far between. These two new teams have made picking rookies even harder.