Anthony Miles Vs Dylan Shiel

[mdub]

Sheil would have to be the most popular mid rook for most teams, but miles has put on some impressive stats with GWS last season.

[Holz]

im not even thinking about deciding between the two before the nab, however at this stage i would give the edge to shiel. From all reports he is the better player. Miles may have scored well last year but add coniglio, tyson etc... and im not sure he will go as well.

[Football Factory]

Shiel at the moment

[upthemaidens]

both

[Presto]

I am waiting for the NAB cup before deciding, it could even be I choose both

[Colliwobblers]

the nore you look into the rooks the more "must haves" you find, but the only must haves are the ones lining up in round 1 and likely to keep lining up after round 1.

Shiel or clifton will be most picked midfield rook i reckon.....

[FisherSaints]

Based on NEAFL stats, Miles scores better in DT then Sheil. But Sheil better in SuperCoach. Almost even though, so watch pre-season.

[upthemaidens]

personally i cant see why not load up on all of em,, if they're getting selected then just pick all