Phil Davis - Marty Clarke

[mmurphy3]

I have phil davis and im thinking of dowgrading him to Marty Clarke thoughts ?

[Matty411]

Good call. Clarke should play 22 games if fit and should avg 70+. Davis is injury prone and will play less and probs avg less.

[Colliwobblers]

Marty Clarke is ripping in preseason, he wasn't great in his last season at the pies, but he is more mature, fitter. And I think more dedicated so atvhisvpriceche is a must for me, will score wellvenough to justify having him, will play all or most games, for me he is a cash cow but probably the last one to be upgraded.

[hardnut]

Davis has not proven he can take the rigours of AFL footy yet. Marty is genuine value, the Danny Stanley of 2012!

[Windigo]

How much is Marty? Philly Davis is a dodgy pick and I dunno how he will go at GWS.

[Tex-Factor]

davis will play all 22 IF he can stay fit...he is a gun defender however he is a lock down defender and as such i doubt his scoring potential. marty clarke all the way.