some advice

Started by unceramonius, February 05, 2012, 03:47:55 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

unceramonius

ok so my mids at the moment are .......  swan, ablett, mitchell, selwood, barlow, shiel
my forwards are  ............franklin, cloke, stevie j, martin, brown, zorko, treloar

now my question is........ i can jiggle it around a bit to get barlow into pendlebury, by removing stevie j for goodes.

what is the better option?
stevie j and barlow?
or goodes and pendlebury for this team?

Off Tap

They are very strong lines, what does your backs and rucks look like?

To answer your question, Pendles and Goodes. Reason being you will be able to pick up SJ alot cheaper own the track and Barlow has a question mark over his ability to score like he did in his debut year, which is what you want.

Mozza3

Quote from: Off Tap on February 05, 2012, 04:31:30 PM
They are very strong lines, what does your backs and rucks look like?

To answer your question, Pendles and Goodes. Reason being you will be able to pick up SJ alot cheaper own the track and Barlow has a question mark over his ability to score like he did in his debut year, which is what you want.

I couldn't agree more.

unceramonius

hmm tinkering a bit more

i can do the following three options

stevie j / barlow
stevie j / s.thompson
goodes / pendlebury

VERY tough decision.  stevie j price is steep, goodes may not fire, but pendles should kill it. already worried about cloke etc

Kuruki

The only problem i see with your midfield is Swan + Selwood + Barlow = Fat midfield donut round 12. If you swap Barlow for Pendels it's still a fat midfield donut round 12. Maybe swapping Barlow for Thomo would be a good option.

Windigo

Yeah, I'd do something about that potential donut.

Depends if you think Barlow is a keeper. Which if he slays he will be.