Main Menu

international rules

Started by truBLUE, October 28, 2011, 10:04:48 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Holz

Quote from: PowerBug on November 08, 2011, 07:29:09 PM
Quote from: ossie85 on November 08, 2011, 07:20:15 PM
Div A: Vic Country, Vic Metro, SA, WA
Div B: Qld, Tas, NT, NSW/ACT
Why not just Vic, SA, WA, NSW/ACT, Qld, Tas and NT/Int. Why should Vic get two teams?? If players aren't good enough to make the original team that's just Tough! I'm sure that SA, WA could easily match it with the best of Vic.

the reason why there is 2 Vic teams is to weaken them, if there was one they would kill everyone

PowerBug

Quote from: Holzman on November 09, 2011, 08:39:58 PM
Quote from: PowerBug on November 08, 2011, 07:29:09 PM
Quote from: ossie85 on November 08, 2011, 07:20:15 PM
Div A: Vic Country, Vic Metro, SA, WA
Div B: Qld, Tas, NT, NSW/ACT
Why not just Vic, SA, WA, NSW/ACT, Qld, Tas and NT/Int. Why should Vic get two teams?? If players aren't good enough to make the original team that's just Tough! I'm sure that SA, WA could easily match it with the best of Vic.

the reason why there is 2 Vic teams is to weaken them, if there was one they would kill everyone
Reckon?? Well i think it's unfair. If i were a pro footy player from SA, WA i want to play the best of the state, not half of it twice.

Ringo

Agree with PB why not have one team from each state only. Have just had a look at a possible Qld Origin side and the side I came up with could hold itself in the company may not win but would not be disgraced.  Similary a Tasmanian Origin team coulf aldo hold their head high.  Not sure about NSW Origin though.

ossie85


Did you put Nick Roo in the Qld or Tassie team?

INteretested to see what you came up with!

Ringo

Queensland of course did you doubt.

An interesting fact for you Os is the Gold Coast Suns have more Queenslanders on their roster(9) than Lions (5).

Some names that come to mind for a QLd origin team Dayne Beams, Ben Hudson, David Hale, Jesse White, Kurt Tippett, Ricky Pettard, Nick Roo, Sam Gilbert, Michael Osbourne, David Armitage, Daniel Merrett, Jarrod Harbrow, Cheynee Stiller, Zac Smith, Charlie Dixon, Josh Drummond, Ben Warren, Karmicheal Hunt, Tom Williams, Lachlan Keeffe, Shaun Hampson, Rory Thompson and Israel Folau. Whilst not outstanding will be the basis of a sound team but lacking a little experience.

Ziplock

you're missing a really quality mid there :P

CrowsFan

Quote from: Ringo on November 12, 2011, 05:43:30 PM
Queensland of course did you doubt.

An interesting fact for you Os is the Gold Coast Suns have more Queenslanders on their roster(9) than Lions (5).

Some names that come to mind for a QLd origin team Dayne Beams, Ben Hudson, David Hale, Jesse White, Kurt Tippett, Ricky Pettard, Nick Roo, Sam Gilbert, Michael Osbourne, David Armitage, Daniel Merrett, Jarrod Harbrow, Cheynee Stiller, Zac Smith, Charlie Dixon, Josh Drummond, Ben Warren, Karmicheal Hunt, Tom Williams, Lachlan Keeffe, Shaun Hampson, Rory Thompson and Israel Folau. Whilst not outstanding will be the basis of a sound team but lacking a little experience.
You can't include Roo cos it is state of origin. As in where they were born, and for Roo that was Hobart

PowerBug

Quote from: Ringo on November 10, 2011, 12:23:27 AM
Agree with PB why not have one team from each state only. Have just had a look at a possible Qld Origin side and the side I came up with could hold itself in the company may not win but would not be disgraced.  Similary a Tasmanian Origin team coulf aldo hold their head high.  Not sure about NSW Origin though.
I'll be remembering this thread forever. Someone agreed with me :)