Please rate this team first crack

[Superman1978]

Defenders
Brendon Goddard [STK] [MID] $584,700
Brett Deledio [RIC] [MID] $568,700
Nick Malceski [SYD] $367,700
Brian Lake [WBD] $286,900
Matthew Buntine [GWS] $176,600
Marty Clarke [COL] $170,000
Tim Mohr [GWS] $124,700
Will Sierakowski [NTH] $113,200
Beau Wilkes [STK] $106,600

Midfielders
Scott Pendlebury [COL] $700,500
Gary Ablett [GCS] $689,000
Dane Swan [COL] $661,100
Michael Barlow [FRE] $453,600
Anthony Morabito [FRE] $168,500
Anthony Miles [GWS] $113,200
Dylan Shiel [GWS] $113,200
James McDonald [GWS] $106,600

Rucks
Aaron Sandilands [FRE] $600,500
Matthew Leuenberger [BRL] $554,200
Jonathan Giles [GWS] $126,700
Orren Stephensen [GEE] $106,600

Forwards
Lance Franklin [HAW] $600,600
Nathan Fyfe [FRE] [MID] $585,700
Dustin Martin [RIC] [MID] $536,200
Jonathan Brown [BRL] $397,900
Alan Didak [COL] [MID] $336,100
Jason Porplyzia [ADE] $229,600
Nick Haynes [GWS] [MID] $166,600
Taylor Adams [GWS] [MID] $136,600
Adam Treloar [GWS] [MID] $113,200

Money left over $4,700

[Ringo]

Backs: 2 mid priced in Malceski and Lake could pay off but coming off injuries. Probably only would take one as a precaution.
Mids no real problems some will question Morabito but have no problem
Rucks: OK
Forwards: Personally do not like Didak but he may turn it around this year.

Overall 8.5/10

[Luigi197]

I can't really comment much on the rookies as i havent done enough research in that area, but i'll do my best for everything else.

I agree with Ringo, in the fact that you should take only one of Malceski and Lake, I don't mind either of them really, but i haven't seen Malceski in many teams this year, so maybe that's a sign.
For Barlow, he will never be an 100% lock until we see him in pre-season, so read reports and check on how he's doing. Because his injury was pretty bad, and he may never be the same again...
The rest is pretty good, although the forwards is the risk factor, where you have all Brown, Didak and Porplyzia. Although significantly underpriced, they could go terribly wrong if they dont turn their form around. Therefore would rather one more rookie in there to free up some cash.

8.5/10 :)

[cdonny]

I like the pick of Marty Clarke in the backline - if he gets a game that is...

With your mids, whilst you have the 3 'best' available, it might be beneficial to maybe have 2, if not 1 of those guys... As their prices are bound to drop a bit, save some coin, upgrade targets perhaps?

Personally, I'm loving that James McDonald is so cheap! near 100 ave in 2010, still fit... may be an old sod, but will be worth the punt!  (pretty sure i just jinxed him... body will fail him... crap!)

I'm in the same boat as the other gents, don't rate Didak, a few years ago definitely, but he's turning to mud.

mannnn i just want SC to start already!

[Superman1978]

Thankyou all for your kind wisdom will try am improve side. Any solutions of who I should change????

Thanks in advance.

[Ringo]

I would look at swapping Swan with Selwood. Murphy or similar price prem.  (Help with byes)
Upgrade Malceski with cash left over

[ronl]

I personally like to have min $50,000 left in the bank for that unexpected "emergency" and/or peace of mind.