Stevie J or Beams rest of season ??

Started by BurgerKing, May 31, 2012, 11:20:53 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Who is the better option to complete my forward line ?

Stevie J
5 (22.7%)
Beams
17 (77.3%)

Total Members Voted: 1

BurgerKing

So for the rest of this season, who is better ?
Both have soft games this week and should score heavily.
Same bye week.
Money not an issue.
Cheers

me

can't go wrong tbh lol gl with ur decision

Lions01

Beams for me, Stevie J has been playing a lot of midfield time especially in his 2 big games this year (one without Selwood, the other without Kelly) only a matter of time before he spend more time up forward (in previous years has scored very well playing the position but very inconsistent)

Beams shows no sign of slowing down, still a big part of their main midfield rotation with Swan Pendles and Sidebottom

me

Quote from: Lions01 on May 31, 2012, 11:35:30 AM
Beams for me, Stevie J has been playing a lot of midfield time especially in his 2 big games this year (one without Selwood, the other without Kelly) only a matter of time before he spend more time up forward (in previous years has scored very well playing the position but very inconsistent)

that was my rationale last year, but didn't stop him from averaging plenty more than the next best - chris scott loves him in the mids and always praises his elite or near-elite endurance, so i'm personally expecting him to stay there, while also playing forward a bit as usual

Lions01

Quote from: me on May 31, 2012, 12:00:33 PM
Quote from: Lions01 on May 31, 2012, 11:35:30 AM
Beams for me, Stevie J has been playing a lot of midfield time especially in his 2 big games this year (one without Selwood, the other without Kelly) only a matter of time before he spend more time up forward (in previous years has scored very well playing the position but very inconsistent)

that was my rationale last year, but didn't stop him from averaging plenty more than the next best - chris scott loves him in the mids and always praises his elite or near-elite endurance, so i'm personally expecting him to stay there, while also playing forward a bit as usual

Yep i think its a coin flip, cant go wrong either way.

I personally Like Beams thou think its through consistency or the buzz you get when i see a Pendlebury / Swan /  Sidebottom / Beams passage of play where you can get a +30 in 30 seconds  8)

Ricochet

i would go Beams personally. Expect a big score from Stevie J this week but in the long run i think Beams will come out on top

fertalong

Beams will be more consistent and more servicable througbout DT finals as he will have less risk of being rested.

Barra17

Beams for consistancy, Stevie J for those huge games and not so huge. Should average about the same by the end.