Which two defenders would you choose?

[Madmax75]

In the prelims this week and need to trade out Broughton and Gibbs. I already have Deledio Goddard Fisher Adcock Birchall with Pupolo Lisle and Bachleor on the bench. I have a total of 913 000 to spend so for example if I wanted Bock I cant afford Enright. My opponent has the same situation and he has Deledio Gibbs Goddard Fisher with Murphy Heppel and Otten. Which two would you choose.
Any ideas most appreciated.

[goodes37]

enright and suckling

[Luigi197]

Enright makes it in by a mile.
But shouldn't you make it so you can choose 2, not 1 option if you asking for 2 defenders?

[Madmax75]

Thats what my first thought was both capable of scoring 100 or at least 90 and how many other defenders are there that I dont have without byes that can do that? Bock on fire but if I win he has the Hawks in rd 24 and Hurn doesnt seem to be getting big scores even when WC win big.

[Madmax75]

Yep sorry mate intended to do that will fix that.

[Madmax75]

How do I actually do that it didnt seem to be an option when I went to edit poll??

[Luigi197]

How do I actually do that it didnt seem to be an option when I went to edit poll??

although i cant confirm, you may not be able to change the number of votes per person once its been created, only before.
but its alritee. just get the top 2 candidates ;)

[GoLions]

yeah i dont think you can change it now, but if you can i think it says number of votes per user or something like that. anyways, enright and suckling

[Ringo]

Do you have to trade both as I would be tempted to play Pup as cover for Gibbs and trade Broughton for Bock or Enright depending on who you can afford? By doing this you may be able to use second trade in another area to strengthen your team and negate any advantage your opponent may have.

[Madmax75]

That is a good idea but I only have about 18000 in the bank and the differences are:
Me
Him: R Murphy Heppel Otten (or Gibbs replacement) Hodge Montagna Fyfe J Roo Lecras
Me: Adcock Birchall (Broughton/Gibbs replacements) Mitchell T Cloke Okeefe Petrie

Fyfe concerns me but cant afford him. I think he has either no trades or at the most 1. I could trade Pav but then only for someone with the diff bw Broughton and Enright plus 18k

[Ringo]

Try This
Brougton to Enright
Pav to Boomer Harrvey (Plays St Kilda and Richmind and scored 92 and 125 against them in previous rounds) or Josh Kennedy West Coast playing Brisbane and Adelaide.  probably prefer harvey more reliable won't be rested as North sill chance for the eight.

[Torress]

defenders have been inconsistent this year. suckling and enright for sure! but suckling might suffer against GC as you would assume hawks forwards will take most I
of supercoach pie!id still pick him tho. good luck

[dmac07]

enright and suckling

[Madmax75]

Ringo thats definitely worth considering. If I brought Harvey or someone in then I would have to choose which forward to leave out. Prob Petrie after last week and he may have to play ruck 2 if cox is out. So then keep Gibbs for a possible GF? The thinking being that the points diff bw puopolo and Suckling would be covered by bringing in a Harvey espc if Cox is out?

My team is:
(Differences I have highlighted and his differences below again)
B Goddard Gibbs Deledio Fisher Broughton Birchall Adcock (Bachelor LIsle Puopolo)
C Swan Pendles Ablett Boyd Moloney S Mitchell (Bartel Bewick Mullet)
R Cox Mumford (Thompson J tippet)
F Buddy Rioli Goodes N roo Cloke Petrie Okeefe  (Mzungu Pav C Richo)

His differences: R Murphy Heppel Otten (or Gibbs replacement) Hodge Montagna Fyfe J Roo Lecras