Please Help! 1 trade left and a few outs

Started by bmac25, August 24, 2011, 04:53:45 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

bmac25

I have 1 trade left and a few possible outs this week.  Which of my bench players is stronger and who should i bring in?
Also $113k in the bank and a few of my bench players are MPP's.

B: Fisher, Goddard, Deledio, BROUGHTON, R Murphy, Puppolo, Gilbert (Gibbs, Lower, Tuohy)

M: Gaj, Pendles, Swan, Boyd, MITCHELL, Cotchin (I Smith, A Krakouer, B Jacobs)

R: COX, Sandi (Petrie, McCulloch)

F: Fyfe, PAV, Goodes, Franklin, Rok, Rioli, Higgins (Mzungu, Richardson, Callinan)

Players in CAPS are out or in doubt.

Any help would be very much appreciated.

bmac25

My opponents team as of last week is:

B: Scotland, Gibbs, Deledio, Fisher, Goddard, Bock, Broughton (McKernan, Jacobs, Toy)

M: Pendles, Judd, Swan, Ablett, Mitchell, J Selwood (Heppell, Blease, Callinan)

R: Cox, Sandi (Gorringe, J Tippett)

F: Fyfe, Pav, Goodes, Frankilin, N Roo, Chapman, Petrie (Darling, Howe, Matera)

No idea how many trades left or cash in the bank.

Ringo

As I see it you have your opponnent covered although you do not how he trading but he has Gibbs, Scotland Broughton out in backs , Judd out in Mids and can not cover all. Add to the uncertainity of Mitchell and Cox

Lookin at you team
Backs Lower would be coverage for Broughton if he is named which I suspect he will. Also you have the option of switching Gibbs and Jacobs for extra cover.
Smith and Krak will cover Mitchell and Pendles if he is rested.
Rucks Petrie to cover Cox if rested
Forwards Mzungu to cover Pav but Ricardson and Callinan not playing and if Smith not named may need to switch Mzubgu to mids.

So I would be using the last trade to upgrade Pav who we know probably will not play again to a prem forward of your choice Stevie J, Davis, Cloke, JJ Kennedy and give adequate forward coverage as well as bench.

dmac07

Toss up between trading Broughton or Pav. Would go Broughton > Bock or Pav > Johnson/Davis

Basically, do you want to play Lower & Davis/Johnson or Mzungu and Bock

Likely to get similar scores from Lower or Mzungu, but would back Davis or Johnson over Bock, despite bocks recent good form dont think you can trust him.

So, Pav > Davis for me.