Ruck Upgrade

[Alka]

Currently only have Cox as a ruck premium.
So, who do I trade out: Max Bailey or Zac Smith.

And who do I trade in?
Looking at McEvoy.
Mumford has also scored well recently, any opinions on him keeping up this high scoring?

[Windigo]

How many trades left? Mumford I'll have a definite look at next year?

[Mozza84]

I have exactly the same players and the exact same dilemma.
Im heading towards trading Bailey to McEvoy and having Smith as a backup.
Probably do this trade next week, after I know who I am playing in the first week of finals and what ruckmen they have.

Its a tough one. If you think into the future and know that to make the GF you must win in round 23, so who do they play:

Mumford vs Geelong (@ Skilled)
McEvoy vs Kangaroos (@ etihad)

When Mumford played Geelong earlier in the year he racked up 105pts
When McEvoy played Kangaroos earlier in the year he racked up 112 pts

Pretty even... but I would give the edge to McEvoy. :-)

[Alka]

Mumfords lower price is tempting though, as it gives me more flexibility for any trades I have to make in finals.
Getting McEvoy in would essentially leave me with nothing.

5 trades. However I'm getting Birchall in this week. So these 2 trades would take me to 3 left for finals.
Is it worth the trade, or better to just hold the trades perhaps?

[thanme]

Does it have to be this week?? I'm looking at either McEvoy, or waiting 2 weeks and getting Goldstein.

[j959]

if it has to be this wk then Mummy is the go due to price, he should rise, McEvoy is maxed out.

i was considering my Sandi downgrade (yeah, i know - i was hopeful) this wk but not solid on the ruck upgrades so leaving it for now ...
(not enough trades to play around)

[PowerBug]

McEvoy is the best upgrade option.