Are these smart trades?

[Sammyr1223]

Shaw to Fisher and Mzungu to Franklin this week.. and then possibly Hurley to birchall in coming weeks if possible.

DEF: Deledio, Gibbs, Goddard, Enright, Broughton, Adcock, Hurley - Shaw, A Johnson, Watson
MID: Pendlebury, Murphy, Swallow, Ablett, Thompson, Cotchin - Krakeour, Jacobs, Smith
RUCK: Cox, Smith - Gorringe, Tippet
FWD: Goodes, Pavlich, Sylvia, Petrie, Chapman, Riewoldt, Rioli - Retzlaff, Mzungu, Richardson.

4 trades, $187,300.

[j959]

is it J Roo or N Roo in your fwd-line?

J Roo - off-load for Franklin for sure.
Franklin is the one to get this week.

Fisher I think we can wait a week or two ... Shaw isn't goin to lose you any money this wk.   ;)

[upthemaidens]

i would only bring franklin in if you plan on moving petrie to ruck
also u should keep mzunga even just for his mpp,  4 trades isnt alot just hold off(if u can) until finals

[Ringo]

I would only do the Franklin trade this week basically because franklin's price is on the increase and has a B/e of only 47 this week. If it is J Roo definitely upgrade him but if not take your choice of Mzungu or Krak.

By waiting will also allow you to get an idea if Fishers injury is more serious and he has a B/e of 107 this week as well even though playing Gold Coast.

[PICCOLLO]

Shaw to fisher next week then reassess.  Franklin is a bargain but you dont really have room for him unless you roll with petrie in the ruck.  If you do that then get rid of krak and keep mzungu. 

[Sammyr1223]

It is nick riewoldt..

I would most likely push petrie into the ruck and have smith on the bench (depending on byes)

[JimMundy93]

Move Petrie into rucks then trade krakouer to Franklin
Then your forwards should be set
Then next week trade shaw for fisher

Then you have to trades to sideways for finals but also have Hurley for cover in forward for chapmans/backs for enrights bye and back for Gibbs bye
So you just need to trade Murphy and enright/chapman trade and then you're set