Which ruck trade to make?

Started by Muneem, July 08, 2011, 07:29:20 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Ruck Options

Z Smith to Lobbe
3 (42.9%)
Sandi to Lobbe
4 (57.1%)

Total Members Voted: 0

Muneem

Hey boys,
I'm back ;)
My rucks look this:
Cox, Sandi (Smith and Bailey)
I really want to get rid of Yarran soon, as he has the bye during finals for Fyfe after this week, or ROK this week.
Thanks lads :)

Bosh

Sandi to Lobbe. If you go smith to Lobbe you have to play him for the next 5 weeks wil sandi is back. At least if you trade Sandi you have lobbe and Smith to chose from..

daz123


Ringo

Do you need the cash trade will generate. Will the Cox/Smith/Lobbe combo work for finals.
I would be looking at Sandi to McEvoy so as to have a strong ruck set up for final then downgrading Smith to lobbe if you still need the cash.

essendon33

Quote from: Ringo on July 08, 2011, 07:46:04 PM
Do you need the cash trade will generate. Will the Cox/Smith/Lobbe combo work for finals.
I would be looking at Sandi to McEvoy so as to have a strong ruck set up for final then downgrading Smith to lobbe if you still need the cash.

definatley agree, people are going sandi to griffen/lobbe wayy to soon, yes they arent a bad choice, yeh thay are scoring well, but experience in the afl is very very limited..
look for quality rucks, such as mummy, jamar, mcevoy, petrie...

Slammer

Quote from: essendon33 on July 08, 2011, 07:58:03 PM
Quote from: Ringo on July 08, 2011, 07:46:04 PM
Do you need the cash trade will generate. Will the Cox/Smith/Lobbe combo work for finals.
I would be looking at Sandi to McEvoy so as to have a strong ruck set up for final then downgrading Smith to lobbe if you still need the cash.

definatley agree, people are going sandi to griffen/lobbe wayy to soon, yes they arent a bad choice, yeh thay are scoring well, but experience in the afl is very very limited..
look for quality rucks, such as mummy, jamar, mcevoy, petrie...

Also depends on how gutsy you are. By going Smith to Lobbe, you generate cash and have Sandi back soon for a good ruck combo of Cox and Sandi for finals. Harvey said 3 weeks for Sandi. I reckon he will be back for the Derby. If not you can still trade Sandi for McEvoy closer to finals if he is put in cotton wool for rest of year.

Muneem

I've decided to not doing anything this week. I have 4 trades left and I reckon Griffin could be a better option. :)