Quick poll HELP!!

[junior8]

All have pros/cons

Redden- pro, I dnt have any Brisbane players, form is very good
Con- is he a real premium or others around the price better

Montagna- pro- very cheap, proven mid
Con- down on form of late, already have 3 saints players

SThompson- pro- I don't have any Adelaide Players,, form is good
Con- a little bit up n down plays better in Adelaide, doesn't get the big scores

Selwood- pro- proven mid n can get big scores
Cons- suspension/injury worries, already have 3 cats players n they have bye if I have to play 2nd week of finals



PLEASE HELP

[Justin Bieber]

Poll has Thompson just ahead of Montagna. I too would go with Thompson.

As you said, Redden has the ability but isn't proven (inconsistent as well). Selwood is out on that suspension for another 3 rounds (I think) and then another bye. So you'll only get 5 more rounds of him which I don't think makes him worth a trade in now :(. If it wasn't for that suspension, I wouldn't hesitate in saying go for Selwood.

Down to Thompson and Joey. Went with Thompson although it's hard to split the two. Joey has no more byes but Thompson has a bye coming up. Seeing as you have 3 Saint players already, tipped my vote to Thompson for a little variety and added X Factor to the team. I think you can't go wrong either way so go with your Gut.

*Peace Out Pplz.