The three S's

[Memphistopheles]

If you were going for overall who would you trade in for Heppell this week.

Assume price isn't an issue (which is isnt).

Scotland, Shaw or Suckling?

[thanme]

Scotland! He's captain consistent this year.

[Holz]

Scotland by a long way, if you had to rely on 1 defender posting a good score it has to be this guy. Great for both league and overall.

[Fireballz]

I voted for suckling before i read you were going for overall sorry! Get Scotty for sure!

[Ziplock]

I said Shaw, he has no more byes left, and if he can decrease his inconsistency even more than he already has this season, his average will be very close to Scotlands.

For overall, shaw's inconsistencies are not a problem.

[Alka]

Shaw is better for overall IMO. Plays one more game than the other two, and as Zip says, his inconsistency is not an issue for overall as he will average the same as they will.