James -> Scott

Started by elephants, June 18, 2011, 11:49:19 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Is this a wasted trade?

Wasted Trade
4 (22.2%)
Trade Well Spent
14 (77.8%)

Total Members Voted: 0

elephants

James Bartel out for Scotty Pendles? Wasted trade? or a good move?

Edit: Would leave me with 8 trades for finals.

Ago97

Good move if you hav the trades but if you dont hav trades keep jimmy

elephants

Cheers for the reply. Would leave me with 8 trades and a more or less finished team?

glynman90

Seems to be a waste since Bartel is not likely to miss any games. Don't you have someone else you could upgrade to Pendles?

Ago97

8 trades and a finished team
jeez thats pretty good

elephants

MIdfield is done.

Swan, Boyd, Gazza, Marc, Mitchell, Bartel.

Jimmy isn't scoring at a 105 average like your midfielders should be. My team is done elsewhere with Lower my only starting back rookie. I think that starting one of Lower/Heppell/Hibberd/Poo each week is worth saving the double trade to an inconsistent premium.

elephants

Equally i could bring in Rockliffe. He is only 30 k cheaper that Jim (even after his 2)
I don't have any other players out on that particular bye round....

Fossil11

rockliff or redden both look good

if you want to go unique

a.swallow, rischitelli, redden, rockliff, shiels, barlow

otherwise pendles is your man. maybe mitchell????

elephants

Already have Mitchell.
Rocky is looking like the go if you've seen my other posts :)