Who to start in M7, Hibberd or Didak

[sj9177]

Wow guys, thanks for the thought you've both put into this thread, really appreciate it, gives me tonnes to think about.

Totally agree it looks like a heavy forward line, and right now the team isnt in its ideal config, if everything went well and in magic land no injuries this is how it would look if i had the choice.



That said given byes and obvious injuries ive choses to focus on "overcoverage" of positions.

The big issue as i see it is the back line and thats what im going to work on next

Thanks again for all the great comments

[dominic17]

no problems, at the end of the day its just a couple of nuffies oppinions anyway so you can take what you like from it. but i think you said it perfectly, in a perfect world with no byes or injuries you have one descent player in yarran as cover in the fwds. and one descent player in didak for cover in the mids. but given injuries and byes each week thats never going to happen. im jealous of your team and if all you have to do is upgrade 1 or 2 defenders and your done then thats awsome! you should be pretty confident going into finals with that side

[masterjudd]

Really? You think having either of those three on the bench is a good option? And feasible? Come on buddy, you must be joking.. You wouldn't rather spend that money to strengthen your backs or mids? Over 100ppg is not enough for mids, you need to understand that. Over 115 is needed to win your league matches in finals. My team is much stronger than this and i don't need to rely on underscoring players. Next week his still missing two mid premiums plus didak, then needs to rely on mzungu or hibberd to fill in, or both? How is that not relying on 4th or 5th game rookies? I know not all can play every week, but that's because of a bye! Not because you NEED to bench two fwd prems!

[dominic17]

not sure how well your eyes work? he is now spending money to upgrade his backs. the worst performing mid fielder is averaging 100ppg. then selwood is his next? what more do you want? your a harsh critique mate. how bout you put your team up for ppl to comment on and decide which is stronger?

[masterjudd]

Haha yea don't pay too much attention to us, we both just think we're correct.
Looking at that team I want to change my argument lol.. Your backups are too powerful considering your backline haha.. But yes not a bad team at all. What your overall rank? And how many trades?

[masterjudd]

thats a fair call.. please be critical, i think i need constructive criticism.

Backs: Deledio, H.Shaw Goddard, Gibbs, Enright, R.Murphy, Heppel. (Pedersen, Hibberd, Lower)

Mids: Judd, Pendles, Hodge, Selwood, GAJ, Kraka. (iles, Jacobs, D.Swallow)

Rucks: Cox, Smith. (McCauley, Spencer)

Fwds: Pavlich, Goodes, Nroo, Jroo, Dawes, Rioli,Yarran (Darling, Siposs, Mzungu)

I was going to upgrade swallow this week as i still have $210k left, but my league game doesnt need it just yet. so i might wait for iles to come thru and upgrade him to a mundy or boyd.

Also, i need to get sandi back in, but that wont be hard once i downgrade darling.