Goodes or Fyfe

[Alka]

Forward upgrade. Planning to trade out Harris, hence the MPP.

Already have ROK and Pavlich, so am doubling up regardless (forward line: ROK, Pavlich, Sylvia, Franklin, Chapman, N Roo, Knights). Both have byes in multi-bye rounds, and I am going for league so are good options for me.

Fyfe: Shoulder has me worried. Will Barlow's return mean anything for his scoring?

Goodes: A second half of the year specialist. Now would be great timing for him. Inconsistent recent scores still worrying.

If there's a good option I've missed please mention it.

[Generalsor]

I'd be more inclined towards Goodes but Fyfe will get a little less attention you'd think, with Mundy and Pavlich running around. Havent seen him play since the shoulder twinge so dont know how much it'll affect him.

But considering the injury cloud and Goodes' tendency to finish stronger than he starts i'd lean towards Goodes.

[BillyPil]

Watch Fyfe for another couple of weeks. I've had him since the start, and he has dropped away in the last couple.
He's still trying his little bloody heart out, but I think the body is starting to let him down. He could bounce back after Freo's bye in round 16.

For now it is Goodes all the way.

[Windigo]

Goodes easily.

[BU1101]

+1

Goodes for consistency. Fyfe's shoulder has been a concern but i dont think barlow will bother him, two very different players.

[PowerBug]

Get the Goodes bloke. His name is Adam.

[Alka]

Funny that none of the Fyfe supporters have posted. Looks like it's going to be Goodes.

[BillyPil]

pssst Alka - I'm a Fyfe supporter. See my thread before the season started where I predicted big things for him.
At the moment though, I'm preaching a wait and see message to anyone who asks.

[Andrew]

I've got Fyfe & Goddes and am worried about his Fyfe's shoulders but have no worries with Goodes. Get Goodes at this stage.