Good Trades or bad trades

[Tenfold]

This week  Jack Volt out in Mzungu. Polec out in Joel Selwood.
Next week  A. Krak out in B jacobs. D. Swallow out in G. Ablett.

What do you guys think. Originally was going to keep Jack Volt in and trade Petrie but am $2,000 short of Joel Selwood then if i do that. These trades would complete my midfield for the year.

[sid3bysid3]

mate - why the hell are you trading jack reiwoldt?

if you make that double trade your average will not improve.

you are downgrading a prem to a rookie, then a rookie to a prem... cancels out

[remon tea]

sorry but I reckon your trading plan is very bad :s your week 2 trade looks alright though

[Chelskiman]

No way should you be trading JRoo.  If anything, people would be looking to bring him in to their sides.

[JBs-Hawks]

If your set on trading swallow out may aswell do it this week seeing as he has a bye

[soutter]

One word for those trades - 'Horrible'

[Spooners]

J Roo is a 7th forward AT BEST. Mzungu will probably average the same as him throughout the back half of the season PLUS he is a MPP.

Polec isn't playing, Selwood is a beast - easily a good trade

You might have bigger issues than J Roo but I don't know why everyone thinks he is a DT premium - can score 100 but more likely to hit 70

The Ablett trade is a bit more iffy for me but everyone else seems convinced that 1 good score against the crows means he'll fire all year.

[yorgis]

jeez you're going about it all arse about. drop a keeper to rookie who has'nt played a game yet

[dicey7]

gotta risk it to get the biscuit (or the car)

Get selwood in hes a GUN!

The thing with swallow youve kept him over the bye yet your going to trade him when he returns? he still has bit of cash to make from memory B/E of 55ish

[Ziplock]

I got Jvoldt when he bottomed out. Lastweek I had a mate who I was playing saying 'what do you predict he'll get this week?'

and then when I said 70 he was shocked and was like
'if you knew he was going to do shower why'd you get him in'
and I was just like
-mate, have you seen his finals matchups??? That's why I picked the soab.