BEST CHOICE?

Started by eddyboi, May 12, 2011, 11:54:16 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

who is the best buy

dal santo
5 (29.4%)
cross
3 (17.6%)
kelly
0 (0%)
thomas
0 (0%)
goodes
9 (52.9%)

Total Members Voted: 1

eddyboi

who is the best mid to buy

eddyboi

i already have bartel and swan and montagna

Lekdog

Get mundy if you can ;)

MissPiesFF

I know a lot of members will most likely disagree with me here, but I say get Juddy in. He is a little cheaper than most that avg over 100. Carlton are pulling out all the stops this year. Although Juddy does score better on SC (accuracy and efficency)than DT, I do see his avg rising by at least 10% over the next 4 rounds.

Prospector_1


hardnut

I like Goodes ahead of NDS (only 2 to consider really) as you have Monty and I'm not keen on bringing in players from out of form sides. Plus he opens MPP options. Long term he shoud lbe one of your top 3 fwd and no longer in the mids

Prospector_1

But the question asks "who is the best mid to buy", I take that as a value question.

Without seeing the rest of the team, whatever else needs assumptions to be made.

hardnut

Not sure about that Prospector. I'd say 99% of us would have Goodes in "the ultimate team" where as NDS though a gun (I've had him last few years) woudl be lucky to make 5% of top teams list.
Thereby the "Best Choice" as stated in the thread title has to be Goodes.
My logic anyway but if we all had the same opinion there would be no point asking I suppose.