time for something radical ??

[bundyboy]

hate to say it, but saints are G O N E...and not even looking like it with a really tough 8-9 rounds coming....

so - question whether Roo will do any better than maybe 80 over this time ??

Contrast - Freeo have a really easy run, and Fyfe killing it, and averaging 100+..and MPP bonus

would never have considered it at start of the year, but i think it might  be a trade worth considering.

(can't quite afford chappy)...

ok - other than following the normal rules of not trading premiums (which I argue might no longer apply here) can anyone give me any good reason not to do the trade ??

[MarkPlow]

Can't argue against it

[Windigo]

Depends if you have some trades to burn...

[Fenno]

I thought about it for a second but just can't do it. No matter how bad the saints are you will want Reiwoldt in your team at the end and I just can't trade a player out just to get him back again. Reiwoldt does play well against his next 4 teams so thats the positive I can take from keeping him.

[bundyboy]

20 trades left - and pretty comfortable that way...so still tossing this idea around in my head !!

[Windigo]

Personallt I just couldn't do it. Your trading to a flashy player who is gunning it. But Riewoldt...You just feel more safe-r.

I wouldn't, but at this moment in time. It would work. But who knows what Roo will do??

Really a difficult one BB.

[bundyboy]

tks W....yeh...just hate even thinking about trading him out, but i just see him sliding too much..

what do you think if the trade was for chappy ?? 

got to think again about the overall objective....not going to win the car, so just league and pride now...so come finals time, who do you want in your team???  Fyfe or Roo.  Think the answer is probably Roo...but boy he had better improve!

if the choice was chappy or Roo, i think the question is just as hard if you can't take both....but I think my answer would be different, and go for chappy

[TheHanger]

DO IT. What is life withoiut impulse instincts and risk. DO IT.

I am, every second it looks better and better

[Holz]

definately wouldnt do it, if i had to put money on who will average more the rest of the season, i would be putting it on voldt easy. Its not like broughton with the role change its a form slump, only trade out a superstar if they are injured or have a role change.

[Andrew]

I'm considering Riewoldt -> Chappy as I've got the cash to do it. I'd only sell him for Chappy coz you know Chappy will deliver. Any other forward is too big a risk, even though Fyfe does look like top 5 material.

[bundyboy]

Do it !!

Don't do it...

wish I could figure out how to put this into a vote !!  but I'm just technically challenged  :-[  .... "a man's got to know his limitations ! ".....

[wcarey]

i think you should get fyfe in but not at the expense reiwoldt :-X

[Chopps]

I want fyfe but don't think you should for volt he is a gun saints will/should lift