HELP! Enright or Pendles. Not as easy as it seems...

Started by Archer11, May 02, 2011, 09:42:01 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Which trade would you recommend?

Option1 see below (Enright trade)
8 (50%)
Option 2 see below (Pendles trade)
8 (50%)

Total Members Voted: 1

Archer11

Hey guys Please Help!!!

Backline: Goddard, Gibbs, Lids, Adcock, Grimes, Duigan, Toy, (Ottens, Pederson, Lower)

Mids: Swan, Boyd, Montagna, Bartel, Heppel, Harris (Polec, Atley, Pittard)

$26,100k

Option 1: Downgrade Pittard to Wallis/Hibberd (undecided) and upgrade Duigan > Enright

Option 2: Downgrade Duigan > Hibberd and Pittard > Wallis this week. Then next week upgrade Harris or Atley to Pendlebury

side note: kinda want to leave heppel as my 7th back and the Enright trade would ruin that in the long run. Any other ideas please tell me!!! 

Footy God

Dont get Pendles in unitl after 2nd bye.

Your going to trade him in for 5 rounds before the bye??? Not a good move...

He had an 87 last week, plays Cats in round 8. Should be able to get him for the same price (450k) if not below.

TheHanger

people are too scared of byes this year. we got another 4 trades plus extra emergencys this year so just cop it and get him in for 5 rounds of awesome, one nothing round then more rounds of awesome

bundyboy

gee - no good answers here....

facing same choice - enright and swann my two targets....   

think enright is the way to go, with swann to drop a couple more $$ after poor couple of weeks, plus mid rookies another week to fatten up...

Archer11

Cheers guys. I'll sweat over it for a few more days haha

Ziplock

love pendles. All I need to say :P

that being said, your mids are already very close to being set... I w ould be doing the enright trade now, just since the difference between heppell + harris and pendles is only 40 points, while the difference between someone like duigan and enright is going to end up closer to 50.