Krak->Wallis/Jacobs, nVoldt->Chappy?

Started by Jukes, May 03, 2011, 01:07:37 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Yay or Nay?

Yay, Mitch Wallis
4 (30.8%)
Yay, Ben Jacobs
5 (38.5%)
Nay
4 (30.8%)
A trade very similar to this one (Say in comments)
0 (0%)

Total Members Voted: 1

Jukes

My proposition is to go Krak (Remember last time he smashed it, he then got 3 40's then dropped) to either Mitch Wallis or Ben Jacobs, into Nick Voldt to Chappy. It all works, with a few bucks left over.

So the questions are;
1) Should I turn Krak and Voldt into Wallis/Jacobs and Chappy
and
2) Mitch Wallis or Ben Jacobs?

Chelskiman

NRoo should play this week against the Blues.  I wouldn't be making this trade though, not at all.  If you can get Chappy in then great, but I'd be holding onto NRoo for sure.

Jukes

I'm not afraid that he won't play, just that he's been shower all season.

Chelskiman

So have the Saints in general.  They can't get any worse, meaning their scores should improve over the coming weeks.

Jukes

Saints have hell hard teams coming up (as said on One week at a time), from their next 8 or so weeks they only have 1 winnable games vs Melbourne.

Jukes

Carlton, Hawthorn, Melbourne, Freo (Away), Collingwood, Bulldogs, Geelong are their next 7.

Big_Cox14

Quote from: Jukes on May 03, 2011, 01:34:15 AM
Carlton, Hawthorn, Melbourne, Freo (Away), Collingwood, Bulldogs, Geelong are their next 7.

Out of those teams that the saints have to play before their 2nd bye, the way that the Saints are currently playing I can only see them having a chance of winning against the Dees. The saints were lucky to beat Brisbane IMO. They are a team that look devoid of confidence at the moment. Especially without Hayes playing.

I'm seriously looking at getting Chappy in my side too. I can't see N Voldt being a top 10 forward this year. Krak has a low BE, so you may want to try another trade to get in Chappy if possible.

Jukes

Maybe downgrading Harris to Wallis/Jacobs.

Ziplock

yeah dude, but you have to remember a ton from a rookie means a consistent price rise for the next 2 rounds. Hold krak.

Jukes

I saw Duigan's BE has exceeded his average, so I'm instead trading him down to Jacobs, then putting up Nick Voldt to Chappy. And I'll get 35k-odd left over for future upgrades, which I see Harris leaving and Selwood coming in.

Ziplock

that's a better trade imo, only if jacobs is named of course. Hibberd would be an even better one to go as he's just that much closer to the bubble.

Jukes

I already have Hibberd. And I might as well do it this week so Riewoldt dosen't drop more money and Chappy dosen't grow in money.

Ziplock