Trade Astbury For Otten? Or get rid of Hibberd for Otten?

[kampf]

Current backline is:

B. Gibbs, C.Enright, D.Heppell, B.Deledio, N.Lower, N.Duigan, D.Astbury

Bench: J.Adcock, J.Toy, M.Hibberd


Should I trade out Astbury for Otten? Astbury going down in value... is Otten set to get some decent scores now though? OR should I look at getting rid of Hibberd?

[Yoshi]

For a little less you could trade Astbury for Brodie Smith. Smith should score similar to Otten if not more.

His JS should be good due to Adelaide injuries.

[ENYGMA]

Disagree on Smiths JS, it is a very short term outlook. Otten has better JS and is underperforming atm but will get better

[simma1978]

Absoute Pointless trade to be honest.......

[Rockyr]

I also have Astbury and have come to the conclusion that he is a dud.

You can consider either McKernan to keep the D / F option, but I am a bit worried about his job security.  I already have Otten and I think that Brodie Smith offers good value although he is not a keeper.