Atley to Curnow?

[PICCOLLO]

Missed out on the Curnow train but have an underperforming Foley and Atley who seems destined to score in 40s.  Which one should I trade out if any at all?

[sid3bysid3]

i would trade atley for curnow and keep foley.

its ok to use a trade to acquire cash - you have them for that purpose aswell as LTI.

dont trade foley - he will make you money and score better.

[Alex7089]

Foely will not be the sub every week.

Scoring should improve.

Goodbye Atley.

[PICCOLLO]

I guess the added benefit is I'll probably upgrade Foley before Richmond's first bye and he did improve this week.  Shame I'll get Curnow for the pies game as I doubt he'll crack the ton.

[C-Dogg]

lucky curnow is playing friday night... if hes named on field and not sub def get him in for atley, il do the same if this is the case

[PICCOLLO]

Is there enough time to make the trade once the sub is announced?  It's normally after lock out isn't it?  Most subs seem to be coming from bench listed players so I guess that is a guide.  It's tough given most midrange players will be the sub at one time or another.

[C-Dogg]

plenty of time to trade, as long as u have a pc near by :)

[sid3bysid3]

yep - conclusive i'd say. if curnow named on field friday then bring him in for atley.

[schezza]

Hi guys,

Im thinking to trade foley to curnow for the cash and massive cash rise and then who to buy is my only problem as i still have selwood to coem on the feild for the mids..... lol

[sid3bysid3]

NO - keep foley... you'll regret it.

only bring in curnow for another rookie

[schezza]

y though?? foley is producing through with the goods ........

[richgo]

Dump Foley for Curnow. Make yourself a handy quarter million immediately, and you've the next Barlow - a bloke that costs peanuts that can start on the ground and get consistant hundreds. Foley is a quality player when up and going, but what's next for him? More injury? More illness? More substitue roles? Poor bloke can't take a trick, and hanging your hat on him to come good is a risk not worth the taking!

[Nuffman]

Dump Foley for Curnow. Make yourself a handy quarter million immediately, and you've the next Barlow - a bloke that costs peanuts that can start on the ground and get consistant hundreds.

Bit quick there mate... He's played Richmond and GCS... If he can rip out a 70 or so against Pies, then... then you can start to possibly compare

[tkringle]

Anyone considering trading out Atley for Liba instead of Curnow?