Stanley or Duigan?

[Slap]

One of them will take my final spot on the field.  Stanley vs the Blues, so obviously Duigan vs the Suns.

Would you say Duigan would do well against the inexperienced Suns?  Or is it likely, that they'd end up on each other and experience doesn't play too much of a role.

anyway, opinions please.

[Bluke]

I've benched both... Although I guess Duigan, didnt he tear it up against GC in the preseason? Or was that the Giants???

[Slap]

Not sure, I know GC played WCE and Brisbane Challange 2 & 4.

Matera scored well those games - whether he can duplicate that against Carlton is another story, i think He'll be on my pine this week to see, Darling will start against Port.

I alreadyhave swallow and Harris debuting this week.. I don't wanna place all my GC players on, in case they crash and burn!

[beermee]

why will duigan do well? is duigan special?

why wont stanley do well?

the truth is: noone actually knows! just make a decision.... or flip a coin....

[Slap]

why will duigan do well? is duigan special?

why wont stanley do well?

the truth is: noone actually knows! just make a decision.... or flip a coin....

I realise this, but its not stupid asking the question.  Whether someone knows something I don't, whether it be logic about opponents, grounds etc..  As you said, I'm impartial about them both at the moment, but if someone can say something cool to impress me either way, it'd be worth it. 

[Bluke]

Duigan may do well because he played well againt GC in the preseason.

Stanley is playing forward and forwards are inconsistent. He could ton it potentially, or he could flower it.

At the end of the day though, it really is the toss of a coin.

[thanme]

I'm going Duigan over Stanley, purely because we've seen him play now, and I reckon he'll be better against GC. I'm actually easing back on a lot of my GC rookies this week.