Yes, before you say it, I know, but...

[meow meow]

Just go Fisher to Gilbert. Taylor has had his big game for the year. Gilbert will be consistent at about 100.

[Talisman]

Cheers everyone!

I'm a bit over it - leaving Fisher where he is for the moment, but looking for him to pick it up. I reckon I was just ticked off at Ross Lyon &/or Sam Gilbert - just never heard of a player telling the coach how to do his job - gues that's modern footy, huh? Ah, well, whatever!  :)

[Marstar]

If you are going for league, then I'd say wait it out until a 'must have' defender emerges. If at that point you still aren't happy with his average scores and potential, then make the trade.

No point re-speculating if you think defenders A,B or C will make more points in the long run. When you already went through that process no more than a week ago.

Hope that helps.

[juddyboy]

look its round one! dont trade, sammy fisher is a class player, harry taylor just pulled a massive score, dont trade fisher.. hes one of saint kildas main men in the backline and will produce good scores!