WHO TO START?????

[victa118]

Really don't know who to start this week in defence, mids or fwds. Please help!!!!

Backs - Which 2?
Heppell, Pedersen, Duigan or Toy

Mids - If Selwood plays then which 2, otherwise which 3?
Harris, Swallow, Liber, Conca or Buckley. Or if Selwood doesn't play I could put Heppell in mids and Buckley in backs

Fwds - Which 1?
Matera, Darling or Richardson

Thanks

[victa118]

40 views and no one has an opinion?

[Mish]

duigan and heppell in the back.

harris and conca in the mid.

matera darling in the forward.

[victa118]

Thanks.
Not sure about Conca though. Why wouldn't you start Swallow over Conca?
Richmond are playing St Kilda after all.

[pavlova]

I'd go swallow personally, and I'd certainly consider liber as well - probably before conca this week against the saints. But really luck will dominate which is the best of the 3.

[victa118]

Yeah I have Selwood as well, so if he doesn't play I am thinking Harris, Swallow & Liber with Conca as Emergency.

[karlos]

Heppell, Pederson (both playing defense against good opponents)
Harris, Swallow, Liber in that order (Selwood is looking more and more likely to play though)
Darling>Matera for me, only because WC's main FWD is gone...and I don't know what to expect from a GC forward (who will likely play deep).

The above is depending on selection of course.

[victa118]

Heppell, Pederson (both playing defense against good opponents)

You wouldn't go Duigan over Pederson considering Duigan is a chance to be rebounding a lot of balls off half back?

Darling>Matera for me, only because WC's main FWD is gone...and I don't know what to expect from a GC forward (who will likely play deep).

Considering Le Cras is out, he will have a better opponent on him then he would if Le Cras was playing. Also, Port have some good solid backs. But agree with u about Matera.