Shane Tuck?

[Cruiseon]

The only thing you missed was gene pool which Tuck edges out Ball on.

[ossie85]

+ 1 for Michael, -1 for Travis

[RiOtChEsS]

both no nonsense players, the only way to decide is throw 11 balls in between em and see who comes up with the most :P

[supercoach addict]

I'm talking about Ball right now though, he's not reallly at the form he had at his peak at St Kilda.

[ossie85]

Unfair to compare Tuck at his best with Ball right now. But even if you did, Ball was in a Premiership 22 and Tuck is not in the 15th placed best 22..... I know this argument is about why he isn't, but still.

I feel Tuck would be great for any team.

[Wes Mantooth]

Unfair to compare Tuck at his best with Ball right now. But even if you did, Ball was in a Premiership 22 and Tuck is not in the 15th placed best 22..... I know this argument is about why he isn't, but still.

I feel Tuck would be great for any team.

agreed os, if anything he'd be better with better players around him

[Boomz]

wtf is wrong with richmond? They will bring in an absolute dud has been in Miller but they won't play one of their best players from last year...

[Maca24]

wtf is wrong with richmond? They will bring in an absolute dud has been in Miller but they won't play one of their best players from last year...

Richmond could finish 10th or so aswell. Im sure a rise up the ladder would be great for team morale and membership. Tuck should be in there.

[Andrew3737]

Prob something happening behind closed doors that we don't know about/