what midfield is better

[carlton blues]

1st option is

SWAN,HAYS,A.SWALLOW,J.WATSON,D.MARTIN,D.SWALLOW


2nd option is

HAYS,STANTON,S.THOMPSON,A.SWALLOW,S.MITCHELL,D.SWALLOW

[JoeMontana]

I like your first one, you have Swan from the start, and I like how you have Martin, haven't seen him in hardly any teams yet, if that paid off, you'd be one up on the rest.

Hayes, A.Swallow and Watson are not in lots of teams either, and definitely not in teams all together, so I'll give you a 9 for creativity, even your second one is at least an 8 for being creative. 

[Chopps]

out of the two get the one with swan

[yorgis]

+1