Rate this team, finished product.

Started by spock18, March 17, 2011, 10:15:36 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

What do you rate this team out of 10?

1
3 (150%)
2
3 (150%)
3
3 (150%)
4
3 (150%)
5
4 (200%)
6
4 (200%)
7
3 (150%)
8
4 (200%)
9
2 (100%)
10
4 (200%)

Total Members Voted: 2

spock18

Rate my team out of 10. This will be locked in, pending injuries and team selection...

Def - Goddard, Gibbs, Deledio, Broughton, Grimes, Astbury, Lower. Emg - Stanley, Duigan, Magin.

Mid - Swan, Boyd, J. Selwood, M. Murphy, Foley, D. Harris. Emg - Bewick, Atley, Hibberd.

Ruck - Sandilands, Cox. Emg - Keeffe, Bailey.

Fwd - Franklin, S. Johnson, N. Riewoldt, Yarran, Knights, Krakouer, Matera. Emg - Richardson, Kerr, Darling.

The gold coast players obviously don't start round 1 but ideally my best team. Not sold on Kerr just lacking good forward bench options. (Prestia too expensive.) Feedback appreciated!

spock18


mote

forwards are a little too lite on for me, maybe get rid of either a premium in your mids or foley for a rookie to upgrade someone like yarran orr knights to a prem

elephants


spock18

Looking at the Nab numbers Heppell didn't appreciate as much as other players. Similarly other players just averaged better over the Nab series.

Feel there is more value in the midfield guns as opposed to the forward guns. But on paper forwards do look quite light

Arradin

I might be mistaken here but I believe that Magin didnt get elevated

CronullaGymJunkies

Astbury -> Heppel
Foley -> D. Swallow
Yarran -> best you can afford?????

spock18

Astbury because the ball will be stuck in Richmond's defence, and he will get easy marks.

Swallow is a great player but not yet dt relevent, more of a super coacher atm.

Yarran I like his role and was very consistent over the Nab series, break out year contender.

bigdaddyg

Murphy is a good unique stick with him

spock18

Cheers buddy. Feeling the break-out year from him

Tittan99

Dude you NEED A m/f link maby get in prestia for atly...

spock18

Not going to alter my structure for the sake of d/p players. I see d/p as more of an added bonus. Also my forwards aren't really threatened by the multi-byes.