Which team?? Both r impressive u decide?

[aces-high]

Gday guys have come up with 2 teams the first team is a little different to the rest as there is no swan and god but there is something i like about it. here it is
def-gibbs,lids,broughton,grimes,otten,heppell,duigan emer,smith,stanley,lower
mids-boyd,selwood,pendles,murphy,swallow,harris emer-hibberd,smith,liberatore
rucks-sandi,cox emer-smith,derickx
forwards-buddy,dids,sylvia,n roo,stevie j,higgins,krak emer-c rich,matera,darling

Original team was
def-gibbs*,connors,broughton,grimes,otten,heppell*,stanley emer-duigan,lower,hibberd*
mids-swan,boyd,chappie*,god*,pendles,harris emer-swallow,smith*,libba
rucks-cox,ryder emer-smith,derickx
for-buddy,sylvia*,n roo,higgins*,knights,krak*,prestia* emer-c rich,matera,darling
Could have mcglynn,cyril or jb with one of boomer,stevie j,goodes,gia or pav instead of higgins and buddy.
Which team will score more this year all intel and thoughts greatly appreciated, Cheers!!