Rate and any advice for a rate and a advice on your team.

[Payney_95]

Ok so here's the team:

Back: Goddard, Gibbs, Deledio, Grimes, Adcock, Heppel, Otten    (Puopolo, Duigan, Toy)

Mid: Swan, Boyd, Bartel, Anthony, Harris, Hibberd     (J Pittard, Atley, I Smith)

Ruck: Cox, Jolly   (Z Smith, Derickx)

Foward: Chapman, Franklin, Riewoldt, Sylvia, Knights, Petrie, Krankouer    (Mzungu, Prestia, Richardson)

Cash Left: 92,800


Here's the problems:
1. Ruck combo. Don't know whether to change to Sandi and a mid priced ruck. Who's a good mid priced ruckman?. Since I dont know who to choose for the mid priced ruck i have gone with the Jolly Cox combo.
2. Knights and Petrie. I know Petrie is out for round 1 but i dont know who to trade him for or if i should leave him in. If i traded him now i would probably get him in round 5.
3.Adcock. Whether to have him or use the 92,800 to upgrade him to someone. Someone to upgrade would be...? Or what about Deledio trading him for Broughton or maybe upgrade to Rawlings If i have enough money.
4. NOT have D Swallow. Is it worth an extra 60,000. Its either having Swallow or saving 70,000 and having J Pittard.

Any advice towards anything in my team, will be much appreciated.   Thanks
If you want leave a link on your team and ill rate and give any advice

[Hoggy]

Backline is fine mate. Pretty safe besides maybe adcock but if he fires your laughing.

Midfield, not to sure on a few of your rookies. I would definitely look at getting in swallow and or polec/conca, just a bit more security than atley and smith who it is doubtful will play a lot of games.

Rucks are fine, im nto a big fan of the mid priced ruck stratergy, think 2 premiums is the way to go. IMO cox will be the number 1 ruckman this year so not having sandi is fine.

Forward line is pretty strong. If your not sold on petrie, maybe look at downgrading him to another rookie, maybe matera? or darling? they will most likely just sit on your bench anyways, as mzungu/prestia/richardson will get games over them. This will free up a bit of cash aswell for you to upgrade a few of the rookies mentioned earlier, even go adcock to a premium if your not sold on him.

Hope this helps!

[hally25547]

Backs: Good - nothing to worry about
Mids: I reckon you should get Swallow in
Rucks: They are fine as they are
Fwds: Very strong - if you were to downgrade anyone it should be chapman to a midpricer and then upgrade jolly to sandi and adcock to broughton but that is imo

can you please rate mine
http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,27501.0.html

[cmgb84]

DEF - solid

MIDS - no swallow is a risk. like selection of pittard, not sold on smith

RUCKS - dont rate jolly

FWDS - chappy looks inj and a risk to me. swap mzungu to darling or matera

your Q's

1 - mid price rucks who i looked at were petrie, fraser and hale

2 - petrie will fire IMO so leave him.. i know you have to ride his first 3 weeks. Knights looks good as well, although is a little suspect on inj front

3 - keep adcock!! who else will score at bris?

4 - smith - swallow


rate mine pls
http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,28374.0.html