crammed full of talent

Started by scubasteve, February 28, 2011, 07:48:52 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

scubasteve

Goddard  - Gibbs - Broughton - Malceski - Grimes - Otten - Duigan
                          (Stanley, Toy, Puopolo)
                       
Swan - Boyd - Montagna - J.p. Kennedy  - Heppel - Mzungu
                          ( Swallow, Liberatore, Harris)

                         Sandilands - Cox
                          (Smith, Derickx)

Franklin - Johnson - N. Reiwoldt - Sylvia - Higgins - Richardson - Darling
                          (Matera, Prestia, Callinan)
   $5000 Left

Going for a league win.
Not sure about def - might swap Broughton -> Delidio or Malceski -> Fisher or both.
Please rate out of 10 and please don't hesitate to criticize.

bb2811

what about pav and mcglynn in forwards esp for league win? 

bb2811

fair enough re: pav - I keep on putting him in and then out again - Mcglyn is 350K - he scored well in nab cup and figure if his byes dont count in the league worth it

hawksrule

Im not sure about mcglynn either. He did look good but he's at that price where he should be a keeper and I don't think he's gonna get good enough scores for me to want to keep all year.

Tittan99


scubasteve

yeah he wound up getting the axe cos i needed the extra 80k. just dont like the fact he hasnt played at all in any of the pre season games, no word of him training, and some bullsht about a calf niggle. not to mention his good ol hammys. i just cant shell out that much money with all those doubts.

but in saying that he will probably just come out and get 100+ all season just like every other year

Mooeyj

no offence.
i rllly think that team is way to weak. to many 92,000/97,000 players on your field

scubasteve

4 too many? remember the gc boys come in round 2.
what would you suggest as an improvement? in my opinion none of the expensive rookies (polec, gaff etc) look like they are the kind of players that will dominate. why spend the extra 40 - 50k on them? i reckon for cash cow purposes its better to have cheap rookies. you just have to make sure they will play.
say you want to make 100k off each rookie (just generalizing) in order for gaff to go up to about 250k he will have to get a 60 - 70 score most rounds, meanwhile a cheapy like mzungu only have to pump out 50's to go up to 200k. i dont plan to have any rookies at the end so i dont want ones that are keepers i just want them to make me money.

Mooeyj

the problem is there is just no balance. like it goes from higgins to richardson. you have no players like krakouer or knights, i suggest you get them becausr they are going to do a heap better than darling and duigan. personally i would only have duigan as a reserve

Jukes

Def- Maybe one too many premiums, otherwise good except I'd prefer Coad to Toy.
Mid- Generally weak with a less-than-strong 4th mid.
Ruck- Strong
Forward- Big drop from Higgins to Richardson, you should have Knights or Petrie or Zaharakis, or alll three as I do.

Good team, 782/1000

Rate mine please- http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,27475.0.html

scubasteve

As far as knights goes if he cant play more than a half of footy without getting sore hes not gonna come out and chop. http://www.afl.com.au/news/newsarticle/tabid/208/newsid/108542/default.aspx
Petrie is going to miss the first 2 - 3 games and is an annoying price where in order to have him id have to ditch higgins.
Its really the same deal with zaha. 295k? id rather spend the extra on higgins who is going great atm.
ill probably have to put krakouer in if he's named round 1

whats wrong with kennedy hes only 300k and i think he should get 80+ most weeks and if his form continues and hes likely to get a few 100's.

Big_Cox14

You may want to get rid of Malceski & Callinan. They're both injured.

other than that, the team structure looks solid.

boo-yaa

i like this team, nearly exactly the same as mine. i wouldn't be worried about the structure, guns and rookies is the way to go.