I want this critisized to death.....unless its too good!

Started by Joshy11, March 03, 2011, 10:46:43 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Joshy11

Backs: Goddard, Gibbs, Deledio, Broughton, Otten, Heppel, Coad
          Toy Duigan Puopolo

Mids: Swan, Boyd, Montagna, Murphy, Swallow, Harris
        Hibberd Atley Callinan

Rucks: Sandilands, Cox
          Smith Derickx

Fwds: Chapman, Didak, Sylvia, Riewoldt, Pavlich, Prestia, Mzungu
         Matera I.Smith Richardson

$200 cash :(

yorgis

looks like a fairly good side. i also had chaps and dids, but i'm still not too sure about both of them. might have to leave it till the last minute,as we have'nt seen hide nor hair of 'em

Joshy11

I was a bit worried about dids but he is playing this week and theres still a few weeks til the season starts and chappy is a gun and should do well no matter what

TofReyes

i will be happy to critisize it to death.
first thing i noticed, too many GC players, 2 in each position is too many imo now that theres byes. coad is no good anyway, hes a key position, same with toy, wont score high, i'd get nick lower and magin instead

chapman and didak both carrying injuries, limited preseason, possibly the same with deledio (hasn't played yet, not sure about an injury), the money could be spent better on other players. from what i've heard franklin is set for a big year

i dont think swallows a good buy (assuming its david from GC). i know hes the 1st pick but he got tagged on the weekend and will probably get a tag most weeks because most teams tag at least 2 mids now and i dont think rischitelli will get tagged. krakouer should average a lot more

not enough money in the bank. if one of your guys gets injured in the first few weeks you have to downgrade. i wouldnt start with less than $50k in the bank.

Joshy11

Thanks mate
Coad for his price will do fine...ave 65-70 because he does rack up the numbers plus lower is on the rookie list as is magin.  toy is an out an out gun. But the amount of GC players does worry me with 4 starting but i think my cover is good enough and there byes are over quickly plus for their price they should be good cash cows. Swallow is a star and still found the footy getting tagged in a depleted midfield, krak may not even get a game :/

Chappy and didak do worry me and i strongly considered buddy but those 2 are proven dt guns and should be fine come start of the season and work there way into full fitness.

Money in the bank is a concern but im trying to limit my trades by using it to get a keeper and its not doing anything just sitting there.

yorgis

if you think that chaps and dids will work their way to fitness, why not wait till they come down in price?

RiOtChEsS


Spite

put I.smith in the mid for atley, then get a 92k forward eg darling, then go didak to franklin to eliminate some risk

Joshy11

So you dont think atley will get games?
If i get buddy then il have 4 forwards not playing in a bye round....thats the only reason i opted against buddy. also i dont think darling will play early

Footy God

Personally id go Grimes over Broughton. Both will be goodb ut Freo will slip down the ladder a bit this year imo and Melborune will rise. More potential to knock up big scores as well. Better over preseason (well Broughton has got 50 in one half and 75ish, Grimes has averaged 90ish).

Like Murphy but personally opted to go with Bartel instead. In a better team, Murphy should avergage 105 though I reckon. Bartel has averaged 115 before, could easily return to that class. Perhaps even Jelwood and Pendles over Murphy as well.



Wes Mantooth