Starting too many rookies? Please rate and i'll rate yours.

[bob321]

Going for a league win.

Backs: Goddard, Gibbs, Broughton, Grimes, Otten, Heppel, Puopolo
Reserves: Stanley, Toy, Duigan

Mids: Swan, Boyd, Montagna, J.Selwood, Kennedy, Mzungu
Reserves: Swallow, Harris, Hibberd

Forwards: Chapman, Franklin, N. Reiwoldt, Higgins, Gamble,  Krakouer, Richardson
Reserves: Matera, Prestia, Smith

[SOS#1]

U've spent a heap of $ on the mids! I would be more inclined to have more rookies in ur mids as there is more value there than the other pos. IMO

[Grazz]

Not to many rokies, infact your starting less than me. Keep in mind you may be without Sellwood and Chapman if you have to play in Rnd 2 of our finals. Roos , Cats , Blues and Bombers have the bye in that order of our Finals. Rate it at a 9.

[antonc]

I would put in some Rucks LOL!

[n4cr123]

i would prolly downgrade selwood to a rookie then upgrade a rookie in your defence to balance out your team a bit better...

[bob321]

LOL Forgot about the rucks as they are the same as everyone's: Sandi Cox ( Smith Derickx)

I have already factored in the trades for Gibbs, Selwood and Chappy and that is the main reason i want them at the start. If they start gunning it and i dont have them i wont want to trade them in then have to spend another trade to get rid of them in the finals.

@SOS#1 Which rookie would you reccommend instead of Selwood? I couldnt decide on Conca/Polec and to a lesser extent Gaff none looked especially amazing.

And what do you guys think about Gamble's job security?

[bob321]

@n4cr123 Do you really think balance is that important? The way i reasoned it out was that Selwood would get me more points than any of the other Def/ Fwds i could upgrade a rookie too and therefore the money was better spent there.

[n4cr123]

@n4cr123 Do you really think balance is that important? The way i reasoned it out was that Selwood would get me more points than any of the other Def/ Fwds i could upgrade a rookie too and therefore the money was better spent there.

Yes becuase the rookie mids are the guys that are going to make you the most money and if you dont have any how will you upgrade your forwards and back???