Michael Hurley

[craig22]

is he worth getting?

[Wes Mantooth]

is he worth getting?

lets start with why you think he's worth getting before asking the panel.

[craig22]

just think he may have a standout year and his quite cheap

[Wes Mantooth]

well he avged 82 in 9 games in 2009 and 69 from 19 in 2010.
hird is there, everyone is feeling like summer rain refreshed and he's had 16 (essentially played one qtr) and 48 (in a half) in the mini games and had 60 on the weekend in DT terms. presents strongly but demons defenders were all over him in the latter stages.

ill wait till he gets some more exp under his belt... maybe a 80 avg in SC.

[thornz23]

yehhhh not for me. although i see a lot of people are keen on him. I dnt think he is influential enough as a kpp to be great in terms of fantasy scoring.  Also dnt think he will make that bigger jump from last year to this year so i would think he would still average roughly the same..

[Didds70]

is he worth getting?

It's also a question I'm mulling over daily.Currently have him as my 5th Def with Otten @ 6 & Coad @ 7.I'm confident there's no downside but upside , ?? .Where will he fit in EFC's own plans?I'm assuming KPP FWD(CHF).Does he fit your own structure?He fits my own DEF structure nicely & if I look at others around his price range,personally I can only come up with 2 . P.Bower on the upper limit & Ben Reid.If your'e in the mood to take risk ,go for it.Bit of a Damned if you do,Damned if you don't type situation with him.I'm prepared to go the risk as the rest of my structure is pretty safe & boring.
Just my 2 bobs worth, Good Luck for the year .

[diddley]

i am staying away this year, but have him on my radar for next year. give him another year figuring his way, and to bulk up more. but he will be unstoppable in years to come.

[BratPack]

He's sort of in the Gumbleton mould, a KPP who could break out, but if he tanks he tanks huge. There's better options

[Boomz]

Who are these better options around that price BP? Theres not a lot... He was playing down back last year so u can't really take much from his average... At that price he's worth looking at for sure. Will be our main fwd this year. I've got him atm in my backline.

[nath01]

Yeah im staying away this year. Even when he has been playing well he hasnt been scoring that much.

I have been tossing up whether to have him for a while and i dont think so this year. Saying that though, i wouldnt be surprised if he has a great year

[j959]

i see why the hype surrounds him in terms of excitement on the field but i don't see this translating to SC scoring ...

i'll keep an eye on him this year for next year ... bit like Melksham, once he's put on some bulk think he could smash it ...

[craig22]

i have decided to stay away..essendon with the bye in round 24 helped my decision