Goodes vs O'keefe vs McGlynn

tferrier18 · February 28, 2011, 07:01:50 PM

Goodes:
+ Even though he's been playing deep fwd in NAB, Bradshaw will come back and push goodes up to chf/mid
+ Proven scorer so he's underpriced based on history
- Poor 2010.. since he won't be completely in mids during 2011 how much can his score increase by?

O'keefe
+ Proven scorer
+ Is underpriced due to 2010 groin soreness
- Didn't look amazing vs. Collingwood but to be fair it was his first hit out since surgery
- Will he be tagging in 2011? I doubt it, but question needs to be asked

McGlynn
+ Always improving
+ Potential breakout season
- Carries more risk than goodes/o'keefe
- Consistency (Guess it doesn't really matter though if you're going for overall because the average is all that matters)
- Can he play a full season? Has only played over 20 games once in 5 years of footy

I'm still thinking goodes but I wanna take the risk on mcglynn...thoughts?

ronl · February 28, 2011, 07:37:50 PM

Out of interest, in an interview last week ROK said that it was his idea to become a tagger last year because he didn't feel he could contribute any other way...less strain on the groin. So, post-surgery, maybe his tagging days are behind him and he can work his way back into a mid/fwd role.
I'm going to wait and see, if he starts stringing some scores together could be a good upgrade target.

SydneyRox · February 28, 2011, 08:15:34 PM

I think Goodes and Okeefe are near locks. Cant see either going backwards and at worst will make you $100k if you dont want to keep them.

I worry about Mcglynn, he keeps ducking his head looking for a free kick, and that is one of the reasons that saw him get clobbered by Sandi (I think) late last year and miss games

Tiggerfan · February 28, 2011, 08:30:28 PM

Interesting comment about ROK wanting to tag with an injury. I would've thought it is easier to run around in the forward line than have to shadow a player all day.....
And I'd have to go Goodes

Boomz · February 28, 2011, 08:33:36 PM

Out of those I'd go McGlynn as he has the most upside imo.

MightyLions · February 28, 2011, 08:43:37 PM

Mcglynn > Goodes > O'keefe!

Mcglynn is due for a good season! Expect big things from him this year!

Big Ange · February 28, 2011, 10:52:12 PM

Goodes for sure!!!

Big Ange · February 28, 2011, 10:53:03 PM

spend 20k more and get a guy that will pull in 100 each week McGlynn washed up trash

Goodes vs O'keefe vs McGlynn

tferrier18