Help - please :)

Started by damoc, February 24, 2011, 11:01:04 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

damoc

Backs: Goddard Gibbs Fisher Grimes Adcock Otten Heppell
Toy Lower Puopolo

Mids: Swan Montagna Bartel Anthony Trengove Harris
Swallow Mzungu Andreoll

Rucks: Sandilands Cox
Campbell Curnow

Forwards: Franklin Riewoldt Johnson Higgins Knights Gamble Krakouer
Richardson Matera Smith

$20000 left over. What do you guys think? I love the look of Trengove in the rising Demons midfield. Please comment thanks

Grannyboy

Backline looks good especially if Adcock can get back to his running best in a weak Lions unit. Cox n Campbell will both miss in round 5 hmm. Pretty good midfield there. Maybe another mpp or 2 in there somewhere to help with subs and byes I think you have to take advantage of them this year especially.

j959

B: just be careful (if you're worried about overall ranking), Rd4 you won't have Godds, Fisher and Adcock available.

M: i'm not sure about Trengove in terms of value for money - ie someone of reasonably similar ability to the top rookie prospects like D Swallow could avg the same (around 60-70pts) this year but as a rookie will be at least $200k cheaper ... i think maybe downgrade him and use the cash elsewhere.

this is unless you're banking on Trengove avoiding 2nd yr blues and increasing his avg to 85-90pts a game - if that's the case, good luck to you.   ;)

R: good pick up Granny boy ...

F: you could use some of that saved money from Trengove downgrade here ... first 3 al lfine, but bottom 4 altogether is risky for differing reasons - i think you just need one more consistent/durable type to shore this line up for you.

good luck!

damoc

sold trengove for wallis. gamble to petrie and knights to ROK. gives me MPP for my rucks when cox/sandi misses. and also the extra forward

Grannyboy

Yeah, much prefer version 2.0. Not much wrong with that from what I can see.

FLOPITOUT1

Petrie suspended round 1  :(

yorgis

5 sainters adcock and higgins all out rnd 4 can you cover them ? maybe >>gamble to presti and fisher to broughton duff or lids [ depending on cash avail]

burner11

Carefull on NM, Geel, Ess andcarlton players as they have the byes thru the finals make sure you can cover them with mpp's ;-)