Sandilands vs Chapman

Started by LiveTheDream, February 25, 2011, 12:15:38 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Who do you take?

Sandilands
Chapman

LiveTheDream

My final dilemma. Which is the better choice out of these two ultra premiums?

Comes down to Sandi + Kinghts   vs   Chapman + Fraser

Sandi gets me set and forget rucks, while Chapman would headline an elite forward line!

What are your thoughts? If you don't post, at least vote :)

Alex7089

Hard to vote with no poll!
A very tough one, I'm not sure on Fraser so I'd take the set and forget rucks ;)

LiveTheDream

yeh for some reason the poll took ages to come up

Talisman

Yeah, Sandi - as premium rucks are harder to come by than premium fwds. Plus. you'll inevitably be fiddling with your backs, mids & fwds all year anyway, it's just nice not to have to think about your rucks - 1 less headache!!  :)

LiveTheDream

Good points thanks Talisman, as you said it will be just one less thing to worry about.

Petrie has thrown a massive spanner in the works by getting suspended. I planned for Sandi to by my first upgrade of the year, but as Petrie doesn't rise in price till at least round 5 now, i think ill miss out on too many points by the time I get Sandi.

Surely Knights will perform better than Fraser/Petrie anyway

Alex7089

Just an idea here, but, try putting Tippett form GC on the bench for rucks, with Petrie in the forward line where there is cover for round 1/3. Then move him to the rucks. Silly to miss out on Petrie because of 1 game!

For this strategy to be needed you need to have Smith.